Ultrafast dynamics of electrons and phonons: from the two-temperature model to the time-dependent Boltzmann equation

Fabio Caruso,Dino Novko

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/23746149.2022.2095925

2022-02-15

Abstract:The advent of pump-probe spectroscopy techniques paved the way to the exploration of the ultrafast dynamics of electrons and phonons in crystalline solids. Following photo-absorption of a pump pulse and the initial electronic thermalization, the dynamics of electronic and vibrational degrees of freedom is dominated by electron-phonon and phonon-phonon scattering <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://processes.The" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> two-temperature model (TTM) and its generalizations -- as, e.g., the non-thermal lattice model (NLM) -- provide valuable tools to describe these phenomena and the ensuing coupled electron-phonon dynamics over timescales ranging between few hundreds of femtoseconds and tens of picoseconds. While more sophisticated theoretical approaches are nowadays available, the conceptual and computational simplicity of the TTM makes it the method of choice to model thermalization processes in pump-probe spectroscopy, and it keeps being widely applied in both experimental and theoretical studies. In the domain of ab-initio methods, the time-dependent Boltzmann equation (TDBE) ameliorates many of the shortcomings of the TTM and it enables a realistic and parameter-free description of ultrafast phenomena with full momentum resolution. After a pedagogical introduction to the TTM and TDBE, in this manuscript we review their application to the description of ultrafast process in solid-state physics and materials science as well as their theoretical foundation.

Materials Science,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to describe and understand the dynamic behaviors of electrons and phonons in solid materials on an ultrafast time scale, especially the coupling processes in non - equilibrium states. Specifically, the paper explores the methodological evolution from the two - temperature model (TTM) to the time - dependent Boltzmann equation (TDBE) in order to describe these phenomena more accurately.

### Main problem decomposition:

1. **Electron - phonon coupling in non - equilibrium states**:
- The interaction between electrons and phonons after photo - excitation causes the system to enter a non - equilibrium state. How to describe the dynamic behavior in this non - equilibrium state is a key issue.
- The paper discusses the advantages and limitations of different models (such as TTM, NLM, and TDBE) in describing these phenomena.

2. **Time scale of the thermalization process**:
- After photo - excitation, the thermalization process of electrons and phonons occurs on a time scale from several hundred femtoseconds to several tens of picoseconds. How to accurately capture the energy transfer and scattering mechanisms in this process is an important challenge.
- TTM assumes that electrons and phonons are in two independent heat reservoirs respectively, and describes the energy exchange between them through a coupling constant \( g \). However, this model ignores the anisotropy in momentum space and phase - space constraints.

3. **Anisotropy effects and non - thermal states**:
- In some materials, the strong coupling between electrons and specific phonon modes will lead to the formation of non - thermal states, such as the "hot phonon" phenomenon. How to describe these non - thermal states and their evolution is another research focus.
- NLM describes the non - equilibrium distributions of different phonon modes by introducing multiple temperature reservoirs, while TDBE further considers the changes in the distribution functions of electrons and phonons under full momentum resolution.

4. **Improvement of theoretical models**:
- How to make up for the deficiencies of simplified models (such as TTM and NLM) through more complex theoretical frameworks (such as TDBE) to achieve a parameter - free description of ultrafast dynamic processes.
- TDBE can handle the momentum - resolved distribution functions of electrons and phonons, so it can better capture the anisotropic distributions and scattering processes in non - equilibrium states.

### Formula summary:

- **Basic equations of TTM**:
\[
\frac{\partial T_{\text{ph}}}{\partial t} = \frac{g}{C_{\text{ph}}} (T_{\text{el}} - T_{\text{ph}})
\]
\[
\frac{\partial T_{\text{el}}}{\partial t} = \frac{g}{C_{\text{el}}} (T_{\text{ph}} - T_{\text{el}}) + S(t)
\]

- **Extended equations of NLM**:
\[
\frac{\partial T_{\mu}^{\text{ph}}}{\partial t} = \frac{g_{\mu}}{C_{\mu}^{\text{ph}}} (T_{\text{el}} - T_{\mu}^{\text{ph}}) + \sum_{\mu'} \frac{T_{\mu'}^{\text{ph}} - T_{\mu}^{\text{ph}}}{\tau_{\mu\mu'}}
\]
\[
\frac{\partial T_{\text{el}}}{\partial t} = \sum_{\mu} \frac{g_{\mu}}{C_{\text{el}}} (T_{\mu}^{\text{ph}} - T_{\text{el}}) + S(t)
\]

- **Basic form of TDBE**:
\[
\frac{\partial f_{nk}(t)}{\partial t} = \Gamma_{nk}(t)
\]
\[
\frac{\partial n_{q\nu}(t)}{\partial t} = \Gamma_{