Ultrafast quasiparticle relaxation dynamics in normal metals and heavy fermion materials

K. H. Ahn,M. J. Graf,S. A. Trugman,J. Demsar,R. D. Averitt,J. L. Sarrao,A. J. Taylor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.69.045114

2004-02-19

Abstract:We present a detailed theoretical study of the ultrafast quasiparticle relaxation dynamics observed in normal metals and heavy fermion materials with femtosecond time-resolved optical pump-probe spectroscopy. For normal metals, a nonthermal electron distribution gives rise to a temperature (T) independent electron-phonon relaxation time at low temperatures, in contrast to the T^{-3}-divergent behavior predicted by the two-temperature model. For heavy fermion compounds, we find that the blocking of electron-phonon scattering for heavy electrons within the density-of-states peak near the Fermi energy is crucial to explain the rapid increase of the electron-phonon relaxation time below the Kondo temperature. We propose the hypothesis that the slower Fermi velocity compared to the sound velocity provides a natural blocking mechanism due to energy and momentum conservation laws.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to study and explain the ultrafast phenomena of quasiparticle relaxation dynamics in normal metals and heavy fermion materials. Specifically, the author uses femtosecond time - resolved optical pump - probe spectroscopy to explore in detail the relaxation processes of electron - phonon interactions in these materials.

#### Problems in normal metals
1. **Inconsistency of the two - temperature model (TTM)**:
- The traditional two - temperature model predicts that at low temperatures, the electron - phonon relaxation time \( \tau \) shows a \( T^{-3} \) divergent behavior with temperature \( T \).
- Experimental data show that at low temperatures, the relaxation time \( \tau \) is almost independent of temperature, which is inconsistent with the prediction of the two - temperature model.

2. **Introduction of the non - thermal electron model (NEM)**:
- In order to better explain the experimental results, the author proposes the non - thermal electron model, that is, after the initial excitation, the electron system is not in a thermal equilibrium state.
- By solving the coupled Boltzmann transport equations, the author shows how the non - thermal electron distribution affects the relaxation dynamics.

#### Problems in heavy fermion materials
1. **Significant change below the Kondo temperature**:
- In heavy fermion materials, when the temperature is lower than the Kondo temperature \( T_K \), the electron - phonon relaxation time \( \tau \) increases significantly.
- This phenomenon cannot be explained by the traditional two - temperature model, and a new mechanism needs to be introduced to explain this rapid increase.

2. **Blocking mechanism of electron - phonon scattering**:
- The author proposes that due to the slow Fermi velocity \( v_F \) in heavy fermion materials, the electron - phonon scattering of low - energy phonons is blocked.
- This blocking mechanism is caused by the law of conservation of energy and momentum, thus explaining the significant increase in relaxation time at low temperatures.

### Formula presentation

1. **Relaxation time formula in the two - temperature model**:
\[
\frac{1}{\tau} = g(T)\left(\frac{1}{C_1}+\frac{1}{C_2}\right)
\]
where \( g(T) \) is the energy transfer rate per unit temperature difference, and \( C_1 \) and \( C_2 \) are the specific heat capacities of the two systems respectively.

2. **Electron - phonon scattering rate**:
\[
\left[\frac{df_{\epsilon}}{dt}\right]_{ep}=\int d\omega K_{ep}\left\{[f_{\epsilon + \omega}(1 - f_{\epsilon})(b_{\omega}+1)-f_{\epsilon}(1 - f_{\epsilon + \omega})b_{\omega}]D_p(\omega)D_e(\epsilon+\omega)+[f_{\epsilon-\omega}(1 - f_{\epsilon})b_{\omega}-f_{\epsilon}(1 - f_{\epsilon-\omega})(b_{\omega}+1)]D_p(\omega)D_e(\epsilon-\omega)\right\}
\]

3. **Electron - electron scattering rate**:
\[
\left[\frac{df_{\epsilon}}{dt}\right]_{ee}=\int d\epsilon' d\epsilon''\frac{1}{2}K_{ee}\left\{-f_{\epsilon}f_{\epsilon'}(1 - f_{\epsilon''})(1 - f_{\epsi}
\]