Integrating Landscape Character Assessment with Community Values in a Scenic Evaluation Methodology for Regional Landscape Planning

Ata Tara,Gillian Lawson,Wendy Davies,Alan Chenoweth,Georgina Pratten
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/land13020169
IF: 3.905
2024-02-01
Land
Abstract:The Landscape Character Assessment (LCA) method from the UK has proven effective in identifying landscape values and characteristics through a comprehensive mapping process. However, it is predominantly expert-led and lacks an evaluation of scenery, hindering the inclusion of the broader community's preferences and visual attachment to their landscape. In Australia, the application of the Scenic Amenity Methodology (SAM) using Geographical Information System (GIS) mapping has engaged communities but has often overlooked the importance of landscape character. To overcome these limitations, this study presents an innovative scenic assessment methodology, referred to as modified Scenic Amenity Methodology (modified SAM). The methodology establishes landscape character types (LCTs) to map scenic preference ratings derived from community photo surveys. Simultaneously, it incorporates the visual exposure of the landscape from publicly accessible viewpoints, modelled using a Digital Elevation Model (DEM). The combination of scenic preferences and visual exposure enables mapping of the scenic amenity values held by the community. This methodology was first trialled in Bundaberg, then Cairns, the Whitsunday Islands, and, most recently, Toowoomba in Queensland, Australia. This paper presents the results of the Toowoomba study and reports on the challenges and limitations of informing landscape character type (LCT) values through a public photo survey, developing a scenic preference map from ratings of photos across a region, a map of the visual exposure of landscape elements from key public viewing locations, and, ultimately, a map of scenic amenity values across the Toowoomba Region. It indicates that integrating previous LCA approaches with public participation through community preferences is indeed feasible for regional landscape planning.
environmental studies
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the limitations of existing landscape assessment methods in regional landscape planning. Specifically: 1. Although the Landscape Character Assessment (LCA) method can effectively identify landscape values and characteristics, it mainly relies on expert judgment, lacks evaluation of scenery, and fails to fully incorporate the preferences and visual attachments of the broader community. 2. The Scenic Amenity Methodology (SAM) method, through the combination of Geographic Information System (GIS) mapping and community participation, can reflect the community's preference for scenery, but often ignores the importance of landscape characteristics in application. To solve these problems, this study proposes an innovative scenery assessment method, namely the Modified Scenic Amenity Methodology (modified SAM). This method aims to overcome the respective limitations by combining the advantages of LCA and SAM. Specific improvements include: - Establishing Landscape Character Types (LCTs): Through a detailed mapping process, different types of landscape characteristics are identified and classified. - Integrating community photo surveys: Obtain scenery preference scores from photo surveys of community members and map them onto the map. - Combining visual exposure analysis: Use Digital Elevation Model (DEM) to simulate the visual exposure of publicly accessible viewpoints to assess the relative visibility of different parts of the landscape. Through these improvements, this method can better reflect the community's preference for scenery and combine these preferences with landscape characteristics, thereby providing more comprehensive and accurate information support for regional landscape planning. ### Formula Summary The formulas involved in the paper are used to calculate the Scenic Preference (SP) and Visual Exposure (VE), and finally generate the Scenic Amenity Rating. The specific formulas are as follows: \[ \text{Scenic preference} = \text{LCT map} (\text{mean SPR for each LCT}) \times \text{LCT subtypes} (1–10) \] Where: - **SPR** represents the mean Scenic Preference Rating for each photo. - **LCT** represents Landscape Character Type. - **LCT subtypes** represent landscape character subtypes, with a scoring range from 1 to 10. Through this comprehensive method, the research team was able to successfully test and apply this modified scenery assessment method in the Toowoomba area, providing strong support for regional landscape planning.