An in vitro assessment of the residual dentin after using three minimally invasive caries removal techniques

Rand Mohammed Al-Sagheer,Ali J. Addie,Lamis A. Al-Taee
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-57745-0
IF: 4.6
2024-03-28
Scientific Reports
Abstract:To evaluate the efficiency and effectiveness of three minimally invasive (MI) techniques in removing deep dentin carious lesions. Forty extracted carious molars were treated by conventional rotary excavation (control), chemomechanical caries removal agent (Brix 3000), ultrasonic abrasion (WOODPECKER, GUILIN, China); and Er, Cr: YSGG laser ablation (BIOLASE San Clemente, CA, USA). The assessments include; the excavation time, DIAGNOdent pen, Raman spectroscopy, Vickers microhardness, and scanning electron microscope combined with energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (SEM–EDX). The rotary method recorded the shortest excavation time (p < 0.001), Brix 3000 gel was the slowest. DIAGNOdent pen values ranged between 14 and 18 in the remaining dentin and laser-ablated surfaces recorded the lowest reading (p < 0.001). The Ca:P ratios of the remaining dentin were close to sound dentin after all excavation methods; however, it was higher in the ultrasonic technique (p < 0.05). The bur-excavated dentin showed higher phosphate and lower matrix contents with higher tissue hardness that was comparable to sound dentin indicating the non-selectiveness of this technique in removing the potentially repairable dentin tissue. In contrast, the MI techniques exhibited lower phosphate and higher organic contents associated with lower microhardness in the deeper dentin layers. This was associated with smooth residual dentin without smearing and patent dentinal tubules. This study supports the efficiency of using MI methods in caries removal as conservative alternatives to rotary excavation, providing a promising strategy for the clinical dental practice.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the effectiveness and efficiency of three minimally invasive techniques (chemomechanical method, ultrasonic grinding, and Er, Cr: YSGG laser ablation) compared with the traditional rotary excavation method when removing deep dentin caries lesions. Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Evaluate the excavation time**: Compare the time required for different methods to remove caries. 2. **Detect the quality of the remaining dentin**: Use DIAGNOdent pen, Raman spectroscopy, Vickers micro - hardness test, and scanning electron microscope combined with energy - dispersive X - ray spectroscopy (SEM - EDX) to evaluate the chemical composition, organic composition, hardness, and microstructure of the remaining dentin. ### Research Background Although the traditional rotary excavation method is fast, it can cause adverse biological reactions in the dentin - pulp complex, such as damage caused by heat and vibration, and non - selectively remove healthy and diseased tissues. Therefore, finding effective minimally invasive techniques to preserve some remineralizable tissues while removing the dentin contaminated by bacteria and denatured on the surface has become an important goal in stomatological research. ### Main Research Methods - **Sample Preparation**: Collect 40 molars with caries removed due to periodontal reasons and divide them into four groups, with 10 teeth in each group. - **Experimental Methods**: - **Rotary Excavation**: Use tungsten - carbide round burs under a low - speed handpiece. - **Chemomechanical Method**: Use Brix 3000 gel. - **Ultrasonic Grinding**: Use an ultrasonic device with a diamond - coated tip. - **Laser Ablation**: Use Er, Cr: YSGG laser. ### Evaluation Indicators - **Excavation Time**: Record the time required for each method to remove caries. - **DIAGNOdent Pen Reading**: Evaluate the fluorescence value of the remaining dentin. - **Raman Spectroscopy**: Analyze the mineral and organic components of the remaining dentin. - **Vickers Micro - hardness**: Measure the hardness of the remaining dentin. - **Scanning Electron Microscope Combined with Energy - dispersive X - ray Spectroscopy**: Evaluate the microstructure and elemental composition of the remaining dentin. ### Conclusion The research shows that minimally invasive techniques have high effectiveness and efficiency in removing caries, especially in preserving more healthy dentin and reducing the adverse effects on the dentin - pulp complex. These methods provide a conservative alternative for clinical dentistry and help maintain the integrity and repair potential of teeth.