Abstract:Background: Hospitals are confronted with increasing safety demands from a diverse set of stakeholders, including governmental organisations, professional associations, health insurance companies, patient associations and the media. However, little is known about the effects of these institutional and competitive pressures on hospital safety management. Previous research has shown that organisations generally shape their safety management approach along the lines of control- or commitment-based management. Using a heuristic framework, based on the contextually-based human resource theory, we analysed how environmental pressures affect the safety management approach used by hospitals. Methods: A qualitative study was conducted into hospital care in the Netherlands. Five hospitals were selected for participation, based on organisational characteristics as well as variation in their reputation for patient safety. We interviewed hospital managers and staff with a central role in safety management. A total of 43 semi-structured interviews were conducted with 48 respondents. The heuristic framework was used as an initial model for analysing the data, though new codes emerged from the data as well. Results: In order to ensure safe care delivery, institutional and competitive stakeholders often impose detailed safety requirements, strong forces for compliance and growing demands for accountability. As a consequence, hospitals experience a decrease in the room to manoeuvre. Hence, organisations increasingly choose a control-based management approach to make sure that safety demands are met. In contrast, in case of more abstract safety demands and an organisational culture which favours patient safety, hospitals generally experience more leeway. This often results in a stronger focus on commitment-based management. Conclusions: Institutional and competitive conditions as well as strategic choices that hospitals make have resulted in various combinations of control- and commitment-based safety management. A balanced approach is required. A strong focus on control-based management generates extrinsic motivation in employees but may, at the same time, undermine or even diminish intrinsic motivation to work on patient safety. Emphasising commitment-based management may, in contrast, strengthen intrinsic motivation but increases the risk of priorities being set elsewhere. Currently, external pressures frequently lead to the adoption of control-based management. A balanced approach requires a shift towards more trust-based safety demands.

[A safety culture in hospitals]

Five System Barriers to Achieving Ultrasafe Health Care

The influence of environmental conditions on safety management in hospitals: a qualitative study

[Risk management in the hospital milieu: needs and implications]

Keeping patients safe in healthcare organizations: a structuration theory of safety culture

The problem with making Safety-II work in healthcare

Survey and analysis of patient safety culture in a county hospital

Study of the Current Situation and Influencing Factors of Safety Culture in Hospital Patients

Changing Patient Safety Culture in China: a Case Study of an Experimental Chinese Hospital from a Comparative Perspective

Building an organizational culture of patient safety

The Predictors of Patient Safety Culture in Hospital Setting: A Systematic Review

Analysis of nurses' assessment of the patient safety culture in hospital

Assessing Patient Safety Culture: Insights from a Neurological Institute

Patient Safety Movement: History and Future Directions

Patient-Safety Culture among Emergency and Critical Care Nurses in a Maternal and Child Department

[Patient safety and errors in medicine: development, prevention and analyses of incidents]

Assessing Patient Safety Culture in Hospital Settings

Discussion on the influence of patient safety culture to hospital safety management in China

Assessment of patient safety culture among healthcare providers in tertiary hospitals in Malaysia-A cross-sectional study

Safety culture, safety climate, and safety performance in healthcare facilities: A systematic review

Patient safety culture in China: a case study in an outpatient setting in Beijing