Thomas A. Trainor
Abstract:The $p$-Pb collision system occupies a unique position regarding physical interpretation of high-energy particle data. More-peripheral $p$-Pb is indistinguishable from $p$-$p$ collision while more-central $p$-Pb overlaps an interval of Pb-Pb centrality wherein it has been claimed that quark-gluon plasma (QGP) formation is achieved. One basis for such claims is certain features and centrality trends of identified-hadron (PID) $p_t$ spectra, including similarities between $p$-Pb and Pb-Pb spectra. In order to verify or falsify such claims it is essential that PID spectra for $p$-Pb collisions (as a control experiment) be understood in terms of fundamental QCD principles. This article (Part I of a two-part report) presents application of a two-component (soft + hard) model (TCM) to PID spectra from 5 TeV $p$-Pb collisions. Certain issues remaining from a preliminary PID TCM analysis (e.g. proton detection inefficiency) are resolved. Coefficients for TCM model functions previously assumed independent of $p$-Pb centrality are obtained directly from spectra. Jet-related spectrum hard components are precisely isolated and their shape evolution with centrality determined relative to a fixed TCM as reference. In Part II the TCM is further elaborated to describe varying spectrum hard components (and therefore entire spectra) within data statistical uncertainties. The completed PID TCM is then used to investigate properties of spectrum and yield ratios (e.g. $p/\pi$) and $\bar p_t$ data.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects:
1. **Verify or refute the views on the formation of quark - gluon plasma (QGP)**: In recent years, some studies believe that certain data features (for example, specific trends in the particle momentum spectra) observed in small - collision systems (such as proton - proton collisions, p - p; proton - lead nucleus collisions, p - Pb) can be regarded as evidence of "collective effects" (i.e., hydrodynamic flow), and then infer that quark - gluon plasma (QGP) is formed in these systems. In order to verify or refute these views, it is necessary to have a comprehensive understanding of the identified particle (PID) momentum spectra in p - Pb collisions, especially how these spectra change with the collision centrality.
2. **Analyze the composition of PID momentum spectra in p - Pb collisions**: The paper analyzes the PID momentum spectra in 5 TeV p - Pb collisions by applying a two - component model (soft + hard, TCM), aiming to accurately separate the hard component related to jets and determine the law of its shape change with centrality. This helps to understand the basic principles of the particle production mechanism in p - Pb collisions, especially to distinguish the jet fragmentation process from the potential QGP effects.
3. **Solve the problems existing in the preliminary analysis**: The preliminary PID TCM analysis has some unresolved problems, including:
- The problem of low detection efficiency of identified protons.
- Assuming that some key PID parameters do not depend on the p - Pb centrality, this assumption needs to be further verified or abandoned.
- The preliminary method for isolating the hard component of the spectra needs careful follow - up research based on more complete information.
4. **Provide the most accurate description of PID momentum spectra in p - Pb collisions**: Extract the PID hard component by improved methods and reduce the deviation, so as to provide the most accurate differential description of PID momentum spectra in p - Pb collisions.
5. **Establish the most comprehensive understanding of the composition of PID momentum spectra**: The ultimate goal is to comprehensively describe the PID momentum spectra in p - Pb collisions within statistical limitations through the TCM model, ensuring that the model only contains the longitudinal projectile - nucleon dissociation and transverse jet fragmentation processes without introducing other descriptive elements.
By solving these problems, the paper aims to provide a solid foundation for the interpretation of high - energy physics experimental data, especially in exploring important physical phenomena such as whether QGP exists in small - collision systems.