Emergence of two-level systems in glass formers: a kinetic Monte Carlo study

Xin-Yuan Gao,Hai-Yao Deng,Chun-Shing Lee,J. Q. You,Chi-Hang Lam

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/D1SM01809D

2022-03-11

Abstract:Using a distinguishable-particle lattice model based on void-induced dynamics, we successfully reproduce the well-known linear relation between heat capacity and temperature at very low temperatures. The heat capacity is dominated by two-level systems formed due to the strong localization of voids to two neighboring sites, and can be exactly calculated in the limit of ultrastable glasses. Similar but weaker localization at higher temperatures accounts for the glass transition. The result supports the conventional two-level tunneling picture by revealing how two-level systems emerge from random particle interactions, which also cause the glass transition. Our approach provides a unified framework for relating microscopic dynamics of glasses at room and cryogenic temperatures.

Soft Condensed Matter

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to explain the heat capacity characteristics exhibited by glass - formers at extremely low temperatures, specifically the phenomenon of heat capacity being linearly dependent on temperature. This phenomenon cannot be explained by the classical Debye model, which predicts that the heat capacity should be proportional to the cube of the temperature ($C_v \propto T^3$). To solve this problem, the researchers proposed a research framework based on the Distinguishable Particle Lattice Model (DPLM).

#### The main research questions include:
1. **Reproduce the experimentally - observed low - temperature heat capacity behavior**: that is, at very low temperatures, the heat capacity $C_v$ is linearly dependent on the temperature $T$, which is inconsistent with the predictions of the traditional Debye theory.
2. **Reveal the origin of Two - Level Systems (TLS)**: TLS is a microscopic structure that significantly affects the thermodynamic and kinetic properties of glass materials at low temperatures. The researchers hope to understand the formation mechanism of these systems and their impact on the glass transition.
3. **Establish the connection between microscopic dynamics and macroscopic heat capacity**: By studying the movement of particles and voids, explain why TLS dominates the heat capacity at low temperatures and explore how they are related to the glass transition.

### Research methods and results
The researchers used the Distinguishable Particle Lattice Model (DPLM) based on vacancy - induced dynamics and successfully reproduced the linear heat capacity relationship observed in the experiment. They found that this linear relationship is formed by the two - level systems resulting from strong localization. As the temperature decreases, the vacancies are confined between two adjacent positions, forming TLS. The contribution of these TLS in ultrastable glasses can be accurately calculated, and the weaker localization effect at higher temperatures also explains the glass transition.

In addition, the research also shows that the formation of TLS is closely related to the random interactions between particles. These interactions not only lead to the emergence of TLS but are also one of the reasons for the glass transition. In this way, the researchers provided a unified framework to link the microscopic dynamics of glass materials at room temperature and low temperatures.

### Formula summary
- The expression for heat capacity $C_v$ at low temperatures:
\[
C_v = c_1T + c_3T^3
\]
where $c_1$ and $c_3$ represent the linear and cubic term coefficients respectively.

- For ultrastable glasses, the specific forms of $c_1$ and $c_3$:
\[
c_1=\frac{8\pi^2\phi_vk_B^4T_I^2}{\Delta V^3}, \quad c_3 = \frac{14\pi^4\phi_vk_B^4}{15\Delta V^3}
\]

Through these studies, the paper not only explains the heat capacity characteristics of glass materials at extremely low temperatures but also provides a new perspective for understanding the glass transition.