Abstract:Purpose This paper aims to compare the performance of flow pulsation versus flow stirring in the context of mixing of a passive scalar at moderate Reynolds numbers in confined flows. This comparison has been undertaken in two limits: diffusion can be neglected as compared to convection (very large Peclet) and diffusion and convection effects are comparable. The comparison was performed both in terms of global parameters: pumping power and mixing efficiency and local flow topology. Design/methodology/approach The study has been addressed by setting up a common conceptual three-dimensional problem that consisted of the mixing of two parallel streams in a square section channel past a square section prism. Stirring and pulsation frequencies and amplitudes were changed and combined at an inlet Reynolds number of 200. The numerical model was solved using a finite volume formulation by adapting a series of open-source OpenFOAM computational fluid dynamic (CFD) libraries. For cases with flow pulsation, the icoFoam solver for laminar incompressible transient flows was used. For cases with stirring, the icoDyMFoam solver, which uses the arbitrary Lagrangian–Eulerian method for the description of the moving dynamical mesh, was used to model the prism motion. At the local flow topology level, a new method was proposed to analyze mixing. Time evolution of folding and wrinkling of sheets made up of virtual particles that travel along streak lines was quantified by generating lower rank projections of the sheets onto the spaces spanned by the main eigenvectors of an appropriate space-temporal data decomposition. Findings In the limit when convection is dominant, the results showed the superior performance of stirring versus flow pulsation both in terms of mixing and required pumping power. In the cases with finite Peclet, the mixing parameters by stirring and flow pulsation were comparable, but pulsation required larger pumping power than stirring. For some precise synchronization of stirring and pulsation, the mixing parameter reached its maximum, although at the expense of higher pumping power. At the local flow topology level, the new method proposed to quantify mixing has been found to correlate well with the global mixing parameter. Originality/value A new systematic comparative study of two methods, stirring and pulsation, to achieve mixing of passive scalars in the mini scale for confined flows has been presented. The main value, apart from the conclusions, is that both methods have been tested against the same flow configuration, which allows for a self-consistent comparison. Of particular interest is the fact that it has been found that accurate synchronization of both methods yields mixing parameters higher than those associated to both methods taken separately. This suggests that it is possible to synchronize mixing methods of a different nature to achieve optimum designs. The new theoretical method that has been proposed to understand the mixing performance at the local level has shown promising results, and it is the intention of the authors to test its validity in a broader range of flow parameters. All these findings could be taken as potential guidelines for the design of mixing processes in the mini scale in the process industry.

Mixing by stirring: optimizing shapes and strategies

Shape optimisation of stirring rods in mixing binary fluids

A gradient-based framework for maximizing mixing in binary fluids

Numerical Simulation on Fluid Mixing by Effects of Geometry in Staggered Oriented Ridges Micromixers

Optimizing passive micromixers: Enhancing mixing efficiency through computational fluid dynamics and metaheuristic algorithms

Using CFD and Machine Learning to Explore Chaotic Mixing in Laminar Diameter-Transformed Stirred Tanks

Hydrodynamic Intensification and Interfacial Regulation Strategy for the Mixing Process of Non-Newtonian Fluids

Numerical algorithms and simulations of boundary dynamic control for optimal mixing in unsteady Stokes flows

Comparison of three-dimensional flow mixing via pulsation and dynamical stirring: application to the mixing of parallel streams at different temperatures

Machine learning-aided design optimization of a mechanical micromixer

Mixing in microfluidic devices and enhancement methods

An Approach to Mixing Equipment Optimization Based on Flow Pattern Construction

Optimization Analysis of the Staggered Herringbone Micromixer Based on the Slip-Driven Method

Retrospect and Perspective of Micro-mixing Studies in Stirred Tanks

Tuning Mixing within a Droplet for Digital Microfluidics

Numerical design of distributive mixing elements

Computational Fluid Dynamics and Machine Learning as tools for Optimization of Micromixers geometry

Optimization of G1 Micromixer Structure in Two-Fluid Mixing Based on CFD and Response Surface Methodology

Efficiently Generating Mixing by Combining Differing Small Amplitude Helical Geometries

New metrics for measuring 2D uniformity in stirring system based on reconstruction of the particle trajectory

Stirrer design for improving fluidization of cohesive powder: A time-resolved X-ray study