Abstract:This paper studies an optimal consumption problem for a loss-averse agent with reference to past consumption maximum. To account for loss aversion on relative consumption, an S-shaped utility is adopted that measures the difference between the non-negative consumption rate and a fraction of the historical spending peak. We consider the concave envelope of the utility with respect to consumption, allowing us to focus on an auxiliary HJB variational inequality on the strength of concavification principle and dynamic programming arguments. By applying the dual transform and smooth-fit conditions, the auxiliary HJB variational inequality is solved in piecewise closed-form and some thresholds of the wealth variable are obtained. The optimal consumption and investment control can be derived in the piecewise feedback form. The rigorous verification proofs on optimality and concavification principle are provided. Some numerical sensitivity analysis and financial implications are also presented.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the problem of how loss-averse investors make optimal consumption decisions when considering the past maximum consumption level as a reference point. Specifically, the paper studies the optimal consumption problem of a loss-averse agent, where the agent's loss aversion to relative consumption is based on a certain proportion of their historical highest consumption level. To describe this loss aversion, an S-shaped utility function is used to measure the difference between the non-negative consumption rate and a certain proportion of the historical consumption peak. The paper solves this problem through methods such as dynamic programming and the concave envelope principle, and derives the optimal consumption and investment control strategies.
### Main Research Content:
1. **Problem Background**:
- In financial mathematics, determining the optimal investment and consumption strategy by maximizing the utility function is a fundamental research topic.
- The paper considers the agent's dependence on past consumption levels, especially when the current consumption is below a certain reference level from the past, causing the agent to feel greater pain (loss aversion).
2. **Model Setup**:
- The agent is loss-averse, and their utility function adopts an S-shaped utility function, which has different risk aversion parameters in the gain and loss domains.
- The reference level is defined as a certain proportion of the past maximum consumption.
- Through dynamic programming methods, the original problem is transformed into an auxiliary HJB variational inequality problem.
3. **Main Challenges**:
- Due to the non-concavity of the S-shaped utility function, solving the HJB variational inequality becomes more complex.
- By introducing the concave envelope of the utility function, the problem-solving process is simplified.
4. **Solution**:
- Through double transformation and smooth fitting conditions, the auxiliary HJB variational inequality is decomposed into closed-form solutions in different regions.
- Some thresholds of the wealth variable are obtained, which are used to determine the optimal consumption and investment strategies.
- Through a rigorous verification theorem, the effectiveness of the concave envelope principle is proven, and numerical sensitivity analysis and financial implications are provided.
### Main Contributions:
- **Theoretical Contribution**: For the first time, a new mathematical model is proposed by combining loss aversion of relative consumption and the reference point of historical consumption peaks.
- **Methodological Contribution**: By introducing the concave envelope of the utility function, the problem-solving difficulty brought by the non-concave utility function is simplified.
- **Practical Contribution**: Specific optimal consumption and investment strategies are provided, which help to understand the behavior of loss-averse agents in actual financial decision-making.
In summary, this paper provides theoretical basis and practical guidance for how loss-averse agents make optimal consumption and investment decisions considering historical consumption peaks by introducing new mathematical tools and methods.