Robust optimal investment and consumption strategies with portfolio constraints and stochastic environment

Len Patrick Dominic M. Garces,Yang Shen
2024-07-03
Abstract:We investigate a continuous-time investment-consumption problem with model uncertainty in a general diffusion-based market with random model coefficients. We assume that a power utility investor is ambiguity-averse, with the preference to robustness captured by the homothetic multiplier robust specification, and the investor's investment and consumption strategies are constrained to closed convex sets. To solve this constrained robust control problem, we employ the stochastic Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman-Isaacs equations, backward stochastic differential equations, and bounded mean oscillation martingale theory. Furthermore, we show the investor incurs (non-negative) utility loss, i.e. the loss in welfare, if model uncertainty is ignored. When the model coefficients are deterministic, we establish formally the relationship between the investor's robustness preference and the robust optimal investment-consumption strategy and the value function, and the impact of investment and consumption constraints on the investor's robust optimal investment-consumption strategy and value function. Extensive numerical experiments highlight the significant impact of ambiguity aversion, consumption and investment constraints, on the investor's robust optimal investment-consumption strategy, utility loss, and value function. Key findings include: 1) short-selling restriction always reduces the investor's utility loss when model uncertainty is ignored; 2) the effect of consumption constraints on utility loss is more delicate and relies on the investor's risk aversion level.
Portfolio Management,Optimization and Control,Mathematical Finance
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the problem of determining the optimal investment and consumption strategy for investors in continuous time under model uncertainty. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to find robust investment and consumption strategies that maximize investor utility in a general diffusion market with random model coefficients, considering model uncertainty and investment and consumption constraints. ### Main Issues and Background 1. **Model Uncertainty**: In financial markets, model parameters (such as asset returns, interest rates, and volatility) are usually uncertain. This uncertainty can lead to poor performance of traditional investment strategies. 2. **Investment and Consumption Constraints**: Investors' investment and consumption decisions are often subject to various constraints, such as no short selling and consumption not exceeding current wealth. 3. **Robustness Preference**: Investors may be cautious about model uncertainty and wish to find an investment strategy that performs well even in the worst-case scenario. ### Main Contributions of the Paper 1. **Mathematical Model**: The paper establishes a mathematical model for a continuous-time investment-consumption problem that includes model uncertainty and investment and consumption constraints. 2. **Solution Method**: The problem is solved using stochastic Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman-Isaacs equations (HJBI equations) and backward stochastic differential equations (BSDE). 3. **Theoretical Results**: It is proven that ignoring model uncertainty results in non-negative utility loss for investors, and the impact of investment and consumption constraints on the optimal strategy is analyzed. 4. **Numerical Experiments**: Extensive numerical experiments demonstrate the significant impact of ambiguity aversion, consumption, and investment constraints on the robust optimal investment-consumption strategy, utility loss, and value function of investors. ### Key Findings 1. **Short Selling Restriction**: When model uncertainty is ignored, short selling restrictions always reduce the utility loss for investors. 2. **Consumption Constraints**: The impact of consumption constraints on utility loss is more complex and depends on the investor's level of risk aversion. Overall, the paper provides a more realistic and robust approach to determining the optimal investment and consumption strategy for investors by introducing model uncertainty and investment and consumption constraints.