How Correlated Adsorbate Dynamics on Realistic Substrates Can Give Rise to 1/ω Electric-Field Noise in Surface Ion Traps

Benjamin Foulon,Keith G. Ray,Chang-Eun Kim,Yuan Liu,Brenda M. Rubenstein,Vincenzo Lordi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2107.01177

2021-07-03

Abstract:Ion traps are promising architectures for implementing scalable quantum computing, but they suffer from excessive "anomalous" heating that prevents their full potential from being realized. This heating, which is orders of magnitude larger than that expected from Johnson-Nyquist noise, results in ion motion that leads to decoherence and reduced fidelity in quantum logic gates. The exact origin of anomalous heating is an open question, but experiments point to adsorbates on trap electrodes as a likely source. Many different models of anomalous heating have been proposed, but these models have yet to pinpoint the atomistic origin of the experimentally-observed $1/\omega$ electric field noise scaling observed in ion traps at frequencies between 0.1-10 MHz. In this work, we perform the first computational study of the ion trap electric field noise produced by the motions of multiple monolayers of adsorbates described by first principles potentials. In so doing, we show that correlated adsorbate motions play a definitive role in producing $1/\omega$ noise and identify candidate collective adsorbate motions, including translational and rotational motions of adsorbate patches and multilayer exchanges, that give rise to $1/\omega$ scaling at the MHz frequencies typically employed in ion traps. These results demonstrate that multi-adsorbate systems, even simple ones, can give rise to a set of activated motions that can produce the $1/\omega$ noise observed in ion traps and that collective, rather than individual, adsorbate motions are much more likely to give rise to low-frequency heating.

Quantum Physics,Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore and explain the microscopic origin of the anomalous heating phenomenon in ion traps, especially the problems related to the movement of adsorbates on the electrode surface. Specifically, the paper focuses on:

1. **Sources of anomalous heating**:
- The ion trap is a promising architecture for achieving scalable quantum computing, but its performance is limited by anomalous heating. This heating is several orders of magnitude larger than the expected Johnson - Nyquist noise, leading to increased ion motion, which in turn causes decoherence and a reduction in the fidelity of quantum logic gates.
- Experiments have shown that adsorbates on the electrode surface may be the main source of anomalous heating, but the specific atomic - scale mechanism has not been clarified yet.

2. **Generation mechanism of 1/ω electric field noise**:
- The paper pays special attention to the 1/ω electric field noise observed in the 0.1 - 10 MHz frequency range. Many models have been proposed, but the atomic - scale origin of this noise has not been accurately explained yet.
- The author studied the movement of multiple monolayers of adsorbates on gold electrodes through computational research, using molecular dynamics simulations based on the first - principles potential energy surface to reveal how the collective movement of these adsorbates generates 1/ω noise.

3. **Collective movement of multi - adsorbate systems**:
- Through simulations, the author found that the relevant adsorbate movement plays a decisive role in generating 1/ω noise, and identified several key collective adsorbate movements, including translational and rotational movements of adsorbate clusters and multi - layer exchanges.
- These results indicate that even simple multi - adsorbate systems can generate the 1/ω noise observed in experiments, and collective movement is more likely to cause low - frequency heating than single - adsorbate movement.

### Formula summary

The key formulas involved in the paper are as follows:

- Heating rate formula:
\[
\dot{\hat{n}}=\frac{q^{2}}{4m_{I}\hbar\omega_{t}}S_{E}(\omega_{t})
\]
where \(q\) is the charge of the ion, \(m_{I}\) is the mass of the ion, \(\omega_{t}\) is the frequency at which the ion is trapped, \(\hbar\) is the reduced Planck constant, and \(S_{E}(\omega)\) is the frequency spectrum of electric field fluctuations.

- Electric field noise spectrum formula (dipole fluctuations perpendicular to the surface):
\[
S_{E}(\omega)=\frac{3\pi\sigma S_{\mu}(\omega)}{2(4\pi\epsilon_{0})^{2}d^{4}}
\]

- Electric field noise spectrum formula (dipole fluctuations parallel to the surface):
\[
S_{E}(\omega)=\frac{\pi\sigma S_{\mu}(\omega)}{(4\pi\epsilon_{0})^{2}d^{4}}
\]

- Fourier transform formula of the dipole - dipole fluctuation spectrum:
\[
S_{\mu}(\omega)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}d\tau e^{i\omega\tau}C_{\mu,\mu}(\tau)
\]
where \(C_{\mu,\mu}(\tau)\) is the time - auto - correlation function of the total patch dipole moment.

Through these formulas and simulations, the author shows how the dynamic behavior of multi - layer adsorbates leads to 1/ω electric field noise and provides a new perspective for understanding the anomalous heating in ion traps.