Alexandre Silveira,R. Erichsen Jr.,S. G. Magalhaes
Abstract:We develop a novel method based in the sparse random graph to account the interplay between geometric frustration and disorder in cluster magnetism. Our theory allows to introduce the cluster network connectivity as a controllable parameter. Two types of inner cluster geometry are considered: triangular and tetrahedral. The theory was developed for a general, non-uniform intra-cluster interactions, but in the present paper the results presented correspond to uniform, anti-ferromagnetic (AF) intra-clusters interactions $J_{0}/J$. The clusters are represented by nodes on a finite connectivity random graph, and the inter-cluster interactions are random Gaussian distributed. The graph realizations are treated in replica theory using the formalism of order parameter functions, which allows to calculate the distribution of local fields and, as a consequence, the relevant observable. In the case of triangular cluster geometry, there is the onset of a classical Spin Liquid state at a temperature $T^{*}/J$ and then, a Cluster Spin Glass (CSG) phase at a temperature $T_{f}/J$. The CSG ground state is robust even for very weak disorder or large negative $J_{0}/J$. These results does not depend on the network connectivity. Nevertheless, variations in the connectivity strongly affect the level of frustration $f_{p}=-\Theta_{CW}/T_{f}$ for large $J_{0}/J$. In contrast, for the non-frustrated tetrahedral cluster geometry, the CSG ground state is suppressed for weak disorder or large negative $J_{0}/J$. The CSG boundary phase presents a re-entrance which is dependent on the network connectivity.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore how the interaction between geometrical frustration (GF) and disorder affects the magnetic behavior in spin clusters with a sparse random network structure. Specifically, the author has developed a new theoretical framework, which allows the network connectivity between spin clusters to be used as a controllable parameter to study the magnetic behavior of spin clusters with two different internal molecular geometries, namely triangular and tetrahedral, in the presence of disorder.
### Analysis of the Main Problems in the Paper:
1. **Interaction between Geometrical Frustration and Disorder**:
- The paper focuses on how to introduce geometrical frustration in spin clusters and study the interaction between this frustration and the internal disorder of the system. Geometrical frustration refers to the phenomenon that the system cannot reach the lowest energy state due to the geometric limitations of spin arrangements, while disorder refers to the existence of randomly distributed interaction strengths or positions in the system.
2. **Emergence of Cluster Spin Glass (CSG)**:
- For triangular spin clusters, the paper finds that the formation of cluster spin glass (CSG) can be observed even under very weak disorder conditions. The emergence of this glassy state does not depend on the network connectivity, but the influence of geometrical frustration makes the distribution level of the local field \( f_p = -\frac{\Theta_{CW}}{T_f} \) change significantly with the increase of \( J_0/J \).
3. **Emergence of the Classical Spin Liquid (CSL) Region**:
- In triangular spin clusters, when the temperature drops to \( T^*/J \), a classical spin liquid region will appear, and this phenomenon is particularly obvious under strong geometrical frustration conditions. The existence of this region is related to the antiferromagnetic interaction strength \( J_0/J \) within the spin cluster, but has a weak dependence on the network connectivity.
4. **Behavior of Tetrahedral Spin Clusters**:
- Different from triangular spin clusters, for tetrahedral spin clusters, under strong geometrical frustration conditions (i.e., when \( J_0/J \) is small), the emergence of the spin cluster glassy state is suppressed. In addition, tetrahedral spin clusters will not show the inverse freezing phenomenon at low connectivity, while this unusual phase transition will occur at high connectivity.
### Summary:
By introducing the connectivity of the spin cluster network as a controllable parameter, the paper systematically studies the influence of geometrical frustration and disorder on the magnetic behavior of spin clusters. For triangular spin clusters, the emergence of the spin cluster glassy state can be observed even under very weak disorder conditions, and geometrical frustration will lead to the emergence of the classical spin liquid region. For tetrahedral spin clusters, their behavior is more complex, including the appearance and disappearance of the inverse freezing phenomenon, and these phenomena are closely related to the network connectivity.