Abstract:We give several new equivalences of $NIP$ for formulas and new proofs of known results using [T87] and [HOR91]. We emphasize that Keisler measures are more complicated than types (even in $NIP$ context), in an analytic sense. Among other things, we show that, for a first order theory $T$ and formula $\phi(x,y)$, the following are equivalent:
(i) $\phi$ has $NIP$ (for theory $T$).
(ii) For any global $\phi$-type $p(x)$ and any model $M$, if $p$ is finitely satisfiable in $M$, then $p$ is generalized $DBSC$ definable over $M$. In particular, if $M$ is countable, $p$ is $DBSC$ definable over $M$. (Cf. Definition 3.3, Fact 3.4.)
(iii) For any global Keisler $\phi$-measure $\mu(x)$ and any model $M$, if $\mu$ is finitely satisfiable in $M$, then $\mu$ is generalized Baire-1/2 definable over $M$. In particular, if $M$ is countable, $p$ is Baire-1/2 definable over $M$. (Cf. Definition 3.5.)
(iv) For any model $M$ and any Keisler $\phi$-measure $\mu(x)$ over $M$, \begin{align*} \sup_{b\in M}|\frac{1}{k}\sum_1^k\phi(p_i,b)-\mu(\phi(x,b))|\to 0 \end{align*} for almost every $(p_i)\in S_{\phi}(M)^{\Bbb N}$ with the product measure $\mu^{\Bbb N}$. (Cf. Theorem 4.3.)
(v) Suppose moreover that $T$ is countable, then for any countable model $M$, the space of global $M$-finitely satisfied types/measures is a Rosenthal compactum. (Cf. Theorem A.1.)
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the relationship between NIP (non - independence property) formulas and Keisler measures, especially how to understand and prove these relationships through analytical methods. Specifically, the author aims to provide new equivalent conditions for NIP formulas and give new proofs of known results. The paper emphasizes that in the context of NIP, Keisler measures are more complex than types, and from an analytical perspective, this complexity leads to the definition of new NIP theory categories.
### Main contributions of the paper
1. **New equivalent conditions**: The paper provides new equivalent conditions for NIP formulas, which involve the properties of global types and Keisler measures. For example, for a first - order theory \(T\) and a formula \(\varphi(x, y)\), the following conditions are equivalent:
- \(\varphi\) has NIP for \(T\).
- For any global \(\varphi\)-type \(p(x)\) and any model \(M\), if \(p\) is finitely satisfied in \(M\), then \(p\) is generically DBSC - definable.
- For any global Keisler \(\varphi\)-measure \(\mu(x)\) and any model \(M\), if \(\mu\) is finitely satisfied in \(M\), then \(\mu\) is generically Baire - 1/2 - definable.
2. **New proof methods**: The paper uses Talagrand's characterization of Glivenko - Cantelli classes to give new equivalent conditions for NIP formulas, which may have application value in future research.
3. **Distinction of complexity**: The paper emphasizes the analytical complexity differences between types and Keisler measures in the context of NIP. Specifically, Keisler measures correspond to a subclass of Baire - 1/2 functions, while types correspond to a subclass of DBSC functions, and these two subclasses have significant analytical differences.
4. **Local - to - global transfer**: The paper shows how to transfer local results (for specific formulas) to global results (for global types and measures), which leads to new results and new proofs of known results.
### Background and motivation of the paper
- **Historical background**: The concept of dependence was independently introduced in model theory, learning theory, and function theory, and soon showed its combinatorial properties. Laskowski discovered the connection between Vapnik - Chervonenkis results and NIP in model theory.
- **Motivation**: Studying the relationships between different mathematical fields can bring new tools, results, and methods, thereby improving and expanding existing knowledge. For example, stability and NIP appear in model theory and are also applied in functional analysis and learning theory.
### Main technical details
- **Function spaces**: The paper discusses in detail the spaces of different types of functions, such as the space of continuous functions \(C(X)\), the space of semi - continuous functions \(SC(X)\), the space of Baire - 1 class functions \(B1(X)\), the space of DBSC functions \(DBSC(X)\), and the space of Baire - 1/2 functions \(B1/2(X)\).
- **Dictionary of model theory and analysis**: The paper provides a useful dictionary that corresponds the types and measures in model theory to the function concepts in analysis, which helps to understand the connections between these fields.
- **New equivalent conditions**: By introducing new analytical concepts, such as DBSC and Baire - 1/2 - definability, the paper provides new equivalent conditions for NIP formulas.
### Conclusion
This paper deeply explores the relationship between NIP formulas and Keisler measures through analytical methods, provides new equivalent conditions and proof methods, emphasizes the analytical complexity differences between types and measures, and shows how to generalize local results to global results. These results not only enrich the theoretical framework of model theory but also provide new directions for future research.