Abstract:Success in large carnivore conservation often hinges on local residents' tolerance towards those species. Feelings of powerlessness and frustration with wildlife policies can lead to intolerance of the species. In extreme cases, intolerance may manifest in poaching. Thus, changes in policy may influence the tolerance of wildlife. To examine the connections between policy and tolerance, we examined how policy scenarios influenced anticipated changes in tolerance to wolves Canis lupus. We administered a survey in 2015–2016 in the core wolf range within northern Wisconsin, USA. Using hierarchical cluster analysis, we clustered respondents into groups based on their current tolerance of wolves. We evaluated the behavioral intentions of the clusters and examined the influence of policy scenarios on respondents' anticipated changes in tolerance. Finally, using an information-theoretic model selection framework, we assessed the effects of tolerance clusters and demographic factors. The respondents were clustered into three clusters relative to their current tolerance towards wolves: positive, ambivalent, and negative. Each cluster exhibited significantly different behavioral intentions and anticipated changes in tolerance for all scenarios. In all scenarios, respondents who already held positive attitudes towards wolves were significantly less likely to report expected changes in tolerance toward wolves following changes in wolf management. However, respondents who held ambivalent or negative attitudes towards wolves were significantly more likely to report expected changes in tolerance towards wolves following changes in wolf management. Regarding a regulated wolf hunting and trapping season, we observed a Simpson's Paradox, wherein, when examined in aggregate, no clear pattern emerged, but when examined at the cluster level, important and intuitive patterns emerged. Our demographic model results suggest that policy changes resulting in greater state management authority over wolves, especially authority to implement certain forms of legal killing of wolves, could result in significant increases in tolerance for individuals who identify as hunters, have lost livestock to a predator, or are currently ambivalent or negative towards wolves. Our work elucidates the nuanced relationship between tolerance of wildlife and wildlife policy and identifies a potential ecological fallacy.

Integrating moral norms and stewardship identity into the theory of planned behavior to understand altruistic conservation behavior among hunters in southwestern Utah (USA)

Rationality or morality? A comparative study of pro-environmental intentions of local and nonlocal visitors in nature-based destinations

Place-Based Pathways to Proenvironmental Behavior: Empirical Evidence for a Conservation–Recreation Model

Factors affecting the consumption intention of game meats: Integrating theory of planned behavior and norm activation model

Values, Motivations, and Intentions to Engage in Proenvironmental Behavior

Hikers’ pro-environmental behavior in national park: Integrating theory of planned behavior and norm activation theory

The influence of social identity on attitudes toward wildlife

Exploring the efficacy of identity priming and message framing in influencing American attitudes toward trophy hunting

Predicting why people engage in pro-sustainable behaviors in Portland Oregon: The role of environmental self-identity, personal norm, and socio-demographics

Participatory intention and behavior in green cultural heritage conservation: an application of the extended theory of planned behavior

Merging elaboration and the theory of planned behavior to understand bear spray behavior of day hikers in Yellowstone National Park

An examination of the factors influencing engagement in gardening practices that support biodiversity using the theory of planned behavior

The Influence of Environmental Values on Consumer Intentions to Participate in Agritourism—A Model to Extend TPB

Changing the Tolerance of the Intolerant: Does Large Carnivore Policy Matter?

Tacit working models of human behavioural change I: Implementation of conservation projects

Engaging with the natural environment: The role of affective connection and identity

Exploring the influencing paths of natives' conservation behavior and policy incentives in protected areas: Evidence from China

Political identity as a driver of hunter responses to chronic wasting disease in a post-COVID world

Who behaves more pro-environmental in the national parks: A comparison of the tourist and the hiker

What promotes residents' donation behavior for adaptive reuse of cultural heritage projects? An application of the extended theory of planned behavior

Integrating OCBE Literature and Norm Activation Theory: A Moderated Mediation on Proenvironmental Behavior of Employees