GD08 A retrospective study of skin diversity and disease, in the depiction of protagonists vs. antagonists, in popular global animations

Edwina Tang,Faisal Dubash
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/bjd/ljae090.347
IF: 11.113
2024-06-28
British Journal of Dermatology
Abstract:Abstract Our retrospective study explores skin conditions and diverse skin phenotypes in the depiction of protagonists vs. antagonists, within popular global animations. Animations throughout media, across continents, can influence younger audiences and societal perspectives. These inevitably impact self-perception and a patient’s personal experience of skin disease, for example acne portrayed in a cartoon villain. Shan Yu, Disney’s villain in Mulan, is portrayed with darker skin, a distinct beard and scars. The choice to associate skin colour and disorders with negatively portrayed characters drives cognitive assignment of a character’s morality, which thus may drive societal prejudice. We collected data assessing skin colour and dermatological characteristics of heroes or villains, in animations worldwide. The top 10 most popular animations for each major continent were identified and analysed from rankings obtained from the Internet Movie Database (IMDB) website. Animations were collected from Asia, Australasia, Africa, Europe, North America and South America. Major blocs of Asia included the top 10 most popular animations from India, China, Japan, the Middle East and South East Asia. Skin tones were captured and put into four categories: grey-hued, pallor, darker than ‘normal’ phenotype and fairer than ‘normal’ phenotype. For example, a character is classified as darker than ‘normal’ if their skin tone is darker than the majority skin colour for that region. While grey-hued and pale complexions are consistently utilized to portray popular villains, there was a global pattern of using contrasting skin colour, depending on the continent. In Europe and Australia, villains with darker skin colours were more common. Acne, warts and scarring were commonly portrayed in villains. In contrast, African villains with distinct skin tone were fairer, whereas their animated African heroes had a skin tone representative of the majority population. Interestingly, in India, more than half of villains were portrayed with darker skin. Sociocultural and colonial-rooted influence of skin tone in Indian society could explain why over half of its popular villains are darker in skin tone. The availability of skin whitening products aligns with postcolonial bias, suggesting that lighter skin symbolizes power, status and beauty. Skin colour and skin disorders in character portrayal may push the notion of ‘good guys’ vs. ‘bad guys’, thus driving prejudice against particular ethnic groups. Colonial media narratives ‘othering’ ethnic groups exemplify how discrimination and hatred may develop. We propose that animators carefully consider the negative impact of their work, including perpetuation of stigma in society, prior to release into the public domain.
dermatology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?