Abstract:Introduction The recent pandemic necessitated virtual interviews for residency applications. While the travel restrictions have eased, the future of virtual interviews remains uncertain, and more information is needed regarding their impact. The purpose of this study was to assess the impact of virtual interviews on both matched applicants' and program directors' satisfaction with match outcomes. Secondarily, we assessed the impact of virtual interviews on resident diversity. Methods This study received endorsement from COERG (Collaborative Orthopedic Education and Research Group). It consisted of surveys distributed to 24 orthopedic surgery residency program directors and residents in their programs, administered at the midpoint of their second year of residency. The surveys were conducted in 2 rounds: the first round targeted the class of 2025, who completed all interviews in person and served as the control group. The second round, conducted the following year, targeted the class of 2026, who underwent all interviews virtually. Each round involved 2 similar surveys to the ones conducted the year before, 1 for program directors and one for residents. Demographics, including resident race and socioeconomic measures, were also collected along with these surveys. Satisfaction was rated on a scale of 1 to 5, and mean satisfaction scores were calculated. Mann-Whitney U-test was performed for statistical analysis. Results We received a total of 96 responses from residents, 60 in-person and 36 virtual interviewees. Of the 24 residency program directors who received surveys, 23 responded to the first-round survey (95.8%), while 18 responded to the second-round survey (75%), resulting in an overall response rate of 85.4%. Residents who interviewed virtually reported lower overall satisfaction with their residency program (p < 0.01), less satisfaction with a good fit between the applicant and the program (p < 0.01), faculty feedback (p < 0.05), research opportunities (p < 0.05), and the educational curriculum at their program (p < 0.01). Program directors were less satisfied with the timeliness of residents from the virtual cohort (p < 0.05) and the knowledge of the virtual cohort (p < 0.05). We found no significant difference in resident diversity between the 2 cohorts of matched residents. Conclusion Virtual interviews were associated with a reduction in both resident and program director satisfaction with match outcomes. Further, virtual interviews did not significantly increase residency diversity. These findings do not support the use of virtual interviews in the orthopedic surgery match process.

The Impact of Virtual Interviews on Satisfaction and Diversity in the Orthopedic Surgery Residency Match

Impact of the Virtual Format on Plastic Surgery Residency and Fellowship Interviews: A National Cross-Sectional Study

Evaluation of the Virtual Interviews for Resident Recruitment Due to COVID-19 Travel Restrictions: A Nationwide Survey of US Senior Medical Students

The Experience of Virtual Interviews in Resident Selection: A Survey of Program Directors in Surgery

Interviewing Amidst a Pandemic: Perspectives of US Residency Program Directors on the Virtual Format

Perceptions of the Virtual Neurosurgery Application Cycle During the Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) Pandemic: A Program Director Survey

Successful Applicant and Program Director Perspectives on the Virtual Residency Selection Process for Canadian Surgical Subspecialties

The 2021 Neurosurgery Match: An Analysis of the Impact of Virtual Interviewing and Other COVID-19-Related Changes

Interviewing in the Wake of COVID-19: How Orthopaedic Residencies, Fellowships, and Applicants Should Prepare for Virtual Interviews.

Impact of the Virtual Interview Format on Urology Residency Interviews: A Survey of Program Directors

Analyzing the Landscape of the 2021 Virtual Match: A Nationwide Survey of Radiology Programs’ Stakeholders

The Impact of Virtual Residency Interviews on the Geographic Distribution of Integrated Interventional and Diagnostic Radiology Residency Matches

Comment on “Evaluation of pharmacy residency recruitment and interview processes during the COVID‐19 pandemic”

The unique impact of COVID-19 on orthopedic surgery residency applicants and program directors in Canada

Influence of Applicant Interview Format Choice on Demographics and Outcomes from the Residency Match

Changes in Residency Applicant Cancellation Patterns with Virtual Interviews: A Single-site Analysis

Virtual Interviews and the Pediatric Emergency Medicine Match Geography: A National Survey

Understanding the Use of Program Resources During Virtual Recruitment by Psychiatry Residency Applicants

Diversity of Leadership and Its Influence on Diversity of Integrated Plastic Surgery Residency Cohorts: A Study in the Virtual Era

Comparing Perceptions of Virtual and In-Person Interviews: Results From a National Survey of Internal Medicine Residents

Perspectives on virtual interviews and emerging technologies integration in family medicine residency programs: a cross-sectional survey study