Abortion in Scandinavian countries – A reply to Dr Verkuyl's letter

A. Sydsjö

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3109/13625181003650257

2010-03-16

Abstract:to have their abortion at home. These women were pleased to be out of the hospital and had the feeling that their integrity was thus better preserved. They appreciated having their partner, a relative or a close friend nearby during the abortion. Furthermore, they had no doubts about their decision to have the pregnancy terminated and how to achieve this. Somehow it seems problematic or controversial to report as we did on positive experiences in relation to abortion. This gives the impression of conflicting with the nearly universal wish to reduce the number of abortions. However, these are two divergent, but coexisting aspects of the abortion issue. We believe it would be unethical to withhold research findings, such as the relief felt by women steering clear of an unwanted parenthood or avoiding the lack of privacy many women experience as a burden when treated at the hospital. This still holds, even if abortion per se is perceived as problematic from an ethical point of view. Our research shows that abortion usually is not experienced as being either trivial or traumatic. Mixed feelings are common but the feeling of relief predominates in women as well as in men. By no means does this exclude ethical reflections. Even though abortion has been a legal right in Sweden since 1975 there is still reluctance on the part of both the women concerned and others to admit that abortion may bring relief or at least not cause considerable distress. Studies we carried out have shown that, in accordance with the social context, women believe that they are expected to experience abortion as a difficult and horrible act. In our opinion, it is important to state how the women experienced their abortion. The absence of a frank and overt discussion of this issue, and of a frame of reference in this regard, preserves myths about abortion and keeps women in a state of guilt and shame. Research that explores women’s (as well as men’s) feelings and experiences in relation to a termination of a pregnancy are, thus, warranted. Most abortions in Sweden are medical and an increasing number of these are done at home. New abortion methods imply new challenges and necessitate other approaches to prevent unwanted pregnancies. Abortion, when taking place at home, offers more opportunities for the couple to share this experience, which may prompt the male partner to take greater responsibility with regard to future reproductive issues, such as contraceptive use. Efforts to prevent unwanted pregnancies are still mainly focused on the women, while men’s role and male sexuality are not at all associated to the same extent with responsibility for reproduction and family planning. Aborting at home, with the partner being present, highlights that reproductive issues are also a concern for males. This modus operandi could facilitate society’s efforts in reaching men as a target group in this domain.