Abstract:Objective: There is longstanding interest in using EEG measurements to inform transcranial Electrical Stimulation (tES) but adoption is lacking because users need a simple and adaptable recipe. The conventional approach is to use anatomical head-models for both source localization (the EEG inverse problem) and current flow modeling (the tES forward model), but this approach is computationally demanding, requires an anatomical MRI, and strict assumptions about the target brain regions. We evaluate techniques whereby tES dose is derived from EEG without the need for an anatomical head model, target assumptions, difficult case-by-case conjecture, or many stimulation electrodes. Approach: We developed a simple two-step approach to EEG-guided tES that based on the topography of the EEG: (1) selects locations to be used for stimulation; (2) determines current applied to each electrode. Each step is performed based solely on the EEG with no need for head models or source localization. Cortical dipoles represent idealized brain targets. EEG-guided tES strategies are verified using a finite element method simulation of the EEG generated by a dipole, oriented either tangential or radial to the scalp surface, and then simulating the tES-generated electric field produced by each model-free technique. These model-free approaches are compared to a 'gold standard' numerically optimized dose of tES that assumes perfect understanding of the dipole location and head anatomy. We vary the number of electrodes from a few to over three hundred, with focality or intensity as optimization criterion. Main results: Model-free approaches evaluated include (1) voltage-to-voltage, (2) voltage-to-current; (3) Laplacian; and two Ad-Hoc techniques (4) dipole sink-to-sink; and (5) sink to concentric. Our results demonstrate that simple ad hoc approaches can achieve reasonable targeting for the case of a cortical dipole, remarkably with only 2-8 electrodes and no need for a model of the head. Significance: Our approach is verified directly only for a theoretically localized source, but may be potentially applied to an arbitrary EEG topography. For its simplicity and linearity, our recipe for model-free EEG guided tES lends itself to broad adoption and can be applied to static (tDCS), time-variant (e.g., tACS, tRNS, tPCS), or closed-loop tES.

A Leadfield-Free Optimization Framework for Transcranially Applied Electric Currents

Head models of healthy and depressed adults for simulating the electric fields of non-invasive electric brain stimulation

An Operational Approach for Optimizing Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation

[An efficient and practical electrode optimization method for transcranial electrical stimulation]

Optimization of multifocal transcranial current stimulation for weighted cortical pattern targeting from realistic modeling of electric fields

Unification of optimal targeting methods in transcranial electrical stimulation

Individual and group-level optimization of electric field in deep brain region during multichannel transcranial electrical stimulation

Perspectives on Optimized Transcranial Electrical Stimulation Based on Spatial Electric Field Modeling in Humans

Optimizing intracranial electric field distribution through temperature-driven scalp conductivity adjustments in transcranial electrical stimulation

Effect of Electrode Size and Maximum Current Limitation on Multichannel Transcranial Electrical Stimulation Optimization

A simple method for EEG guided transcranial electrical stimulation without models

Electric field simulation and appropriate electrode positioning for optimized transcranial direct current stimulation of stroke patients: an in Silico model

Accessibility of cortical regions to focal TES: Dependence on spatial position, safety, and practical constraints

A computational study on the optimization of transcranial temporal interfering stimulation with high-definition electrodes using unsupervised neural networks

An Optimization Approach for Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation Using Nondominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm II.

Standard Non-Personalized Electric Field Modeling of Twenty Typical tDCS Electrode Configurations via the Computational Finite Element Method: Contributions and Limitations of Two Different Approaches

DeepFocus: A Transnasal Approach for Optimized Deep Brain Stimulation of Reward Circuit Nodes

Population-level insights into temporal interference for focused deep brain neuromodulation

The Pursuit of DLPFC: Non-neuronavigated Methods to Target the Left Dorsolateral Pre-frontal Cortex With Symmetric Bicephalic Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS)

Closed-loop optimization of transcranial magnetic stimulation with electroencephalography feedback

Multi-Region Brain Stimulation Optimization Using Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation