Good fire: quantifying the beneficial ecosystem work of western U.S. wildfires (2010-2020)

Jennifer K Balch,Tyler L McIntosh,Nayani T Ilangakoon,Karen Cummins,J. Morgan Varner,Winslow D Hansen,Kate Dargan Marquis,Crystal L Raymond,Brian J Harvey,Rutherford V Platt
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.12.06.627082
2024-12-10
Abstract:Wildfires are doing necessary work for western US forests that have evolved with fire. Here we define "good fire" as areas that burn in an ecologically beneficial way, with a severity that is analogous to their historical fire regimes prior to European settlement. We focus on low-moderate severity wildfire as this type of burning can promote regeneration, even in the context of a warming climate (Davis et al., 2023). We quantify the amount of forested area (i.e., deciduous, conifer, or mixed forest types) burned in low-moderate severity good fire and compare that to the amount of forested area that received prescribed burns (2010-2020). Our results show that 50% of the forested area burned by wildfires in the western US burned as low-moderate severity good fire. Moreover, the total area of this type of good fire was 3.3 million ha for wildfires (N = 18,126 events), compared with 2.7 million ha for forested prescribed burning (N = 25,761 events) over this same period. Lower severity wildfires are doing important work to promote healthy forests, 23% more by area than accomplished through prescribed burning. We also quantified high severity good fire in systems that historically experienced stand replacement, which represents an additional 10% of the forest area burned. Knowing that fires are likely going to increase in frequency and area with warming (Stephens et al., 2023), our key challenge in the future will be promoting good fire while still protecting lives and property.
Ecology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?