Abstract:Inferring the body mass of fossil taxa, such as non-avian dinosaurs, provides a powerful tool for interpreting physiological and ecological properties, as well as the ability to study these traits through deep time and within a macroevolutionary context. As a result, over the past 100 years a number of studies advanced methods for estimating mass in dinosaurs and other extinct taxa. These methods can be categorized into two major approaches: volumetric-density (VD) and extant-scaling (ES). The former receives the most attention in non-avian dinosaurs and advanced appreciably over the last century: from initial physical scale models to three-dimensional (3D) virtual techniques that utilize scanned data obtained from entire skeletons. The ES approach is most commonly applied to extinct members of crown clades but some equations are proposed and utilized in non-avian dinosaurs. Because both approaches share a common goal, they are often viewed in opposition to one another. However, current palaeobiological research problems are often approach specific and, therefore, the decision to utilize a VD or ES approach is largely question dependent. In general, biomechanical and physiological studies benefit from the full-body reconstruction provided through a VD approach, whereas large-scale evolutionary and ecological studies require the extensive data sets afforded by an ES approach. This study summarizes both approaches to body mass estimation in stem-group taxa, specifically non-avian dinosaurs, and provides a comparative quantitative framework to reciprocally illuminate and corroborate VD and ES approaches. The results indicate that mass estimates are largely consistent between approaches: 73% of VD reconstructions occur within the expected 95% prediction intervals of the ES relationship. However, almost three quarters of outliers occur below the lower 95% prediction interval, indicating that VD mass estimates are, on average, lower than would be expected given their stylopodial circumferences. Inconsistencies (high residual and per cent prediction deviation values) are recovered to a varying degree among all major dinosaurian clades along with an overall tendency for larger deviations between approaches among small-bodied taxa. Nonetheless, our results indicate a strong corroboration between recent iterations of the VD approach based on 3D specimen scans suggesting that our current understanding of size in dinosaurs, and hence its biological correlates, has improved over time. We advance that VD and ES approaches have fundamentally (metrically) different advantages and, hence, the comparative framework used and advocated here combines the accuracy afforded by ES with the precision provided by VD and permits the rapid identification of discrepancies with the potential to open new areas of discussion.

Avian telencephalon and cerebellum volumes can be accurately estimated from digital brain endocasts

Mosaic and Concerted Evolution in the Visual System of Birds

Avian brains and a new understanding of vertebrate brain evolution

Avialan-like brain morphology in Sinovenator (Troodontidae, Theropoda)

How smart was ? Testing claims of exceptional cognition in dinosaurs and the application of neuron count estimates in palaeontological research

The accuracy and precision of body mass estimation in non-avian dinosaurs

Quantitative functional imaging of the pigeon brain: implications for the evolution of avian powered flight

Bird brains fit the bill: morphological diversification and the evolution of avian brain size

New insights into differences in brain organization between Neanderthals and anatomically modern humans

Endocranial development in non-avian dinosaurs reveals an ontogenetic brain trajectory distinct from extant archosaurs

Brain virtual histology of a lizard species (Podarcis bocagei) using X-ray micro-tomography and deep-learning segmentation

Brain shapes of large-bodied, flightless ratites (Aves: Palaeognathae) emerge through distinct developmental allometries

Paleoneurology of stem palaeognaths clarifies the plesiomorphic condition of the crown bird central nervous system

How smart was T. rex? Testing claims of exceptional cognition in dinosaurs and the application of neuron count estimates in palaeontological research

Endocranial morphology of three early-diverging ceratopsians and implications for the behavior and the evolution of the endocast in ceratopsians

Unveiling universal aspects of the cellular anatomy of the brain

Volumetric versus Element-scaling Mass Estimation and Its Application to Permo-Triassic Tetrapods

The Human Cerebellum: A Digital Anatomical Atlas at the Level of Individual Folia

Endocranial anatomy of the charadriiformes: sensory system variation and the evolution of wing-propelled diving

Morphological invariant of the midsagittal deep brain anatomy between humans and African great apes