An alpine plant shows no decrease in genetic diversity associated with rapid post-glacial range expansion

Mackenzie Urquhart-Cronish,Colette S Berg,Dylan Moxley,Olivia J Rahn,Lila Fishman,Amy L Angert
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.11.04.621891
2024-11-05
Abstract:While range expansion is hypothesized to be a mechanism for species persistence under climate change, many eco-evolutionary models describe demographic and genetic processes during range expansion that may decrease genetic variation and increase genetic load at the leading edge (i.e., expansion load). These predictions are related to dispersal limitation at the leading edge driving colonization dynamics, a scenario common in post-glacial range expansion at the continental scale (≈20,000 years ago). However, post-glacial range expansion can also occur on contemporary time scales, such as alpine glacier recession following the end of The Little Ice Age (≈150 years ago) and our understanding of dispersal limitation structuring these instances of rapid range expansion are relatively understudied. Here, we test whether there is evidence supporting the role of dispersal limitation during range expansion following alpine glacier retreat using the native alpine plant ( ) by examining patterns of neutral genetic diversity (single nucleotide polymorphisms) across the history of glacier recession (i.e., glacier chronosequence) across two glacier forelands in Garibaldi Provincial Park, BC. We find weak support for the prediction of increasing clines in genetic differentiation towards the range edge, and no support for decreasing clines in genetic diversity, suggesting dispersal limitation is not characterizing colonization during range expansion, with the implication that the accumulation of expansion load at the range edge is likely not applicable on these spatiotemporal scales. Together, our results suggest that loss of genetic diversity for range-shifting species in the alpine is likely not a key contributing factor to any decreased fitness over time.
Evolutionary Biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper attempts to explore whether the rapid distribution expansion of alpine plants following glacier retreat is influenced by dispersal limitation and whether this influence leads to a reduction in genetic diversity. #### Background - **Climate Change and Species Distribution**: With climate change, many species migrate to polar or high-altitude regions to track their climatic niches. - **Ecological Evolutionary Models of Range Expansion**: Many ecological evolutionary models predict that during species range expansion, dispersal limitation may lead to a decrease in genetic diversity and an increase in the frequency of deleterious mutations (i.e., expansion load), thereby affecting individual adaptability and population persistence. - **Range Expansion Following Glacier Retreat**: Range expansion following glacier retreat can occur on contemporary time scales, such as approximately 150 years after the end of the Little Ice Age. However, understanding of dispersal limitation during these rapid range expansions is relatively limited. #### Research Questions - **Role of Dispersal Limitation**: The study aims to test whether dispersal limitation plays a role in range expansion following glacier retreat, particularly by analyzing the neutral genetic diversity (single nucleotide polymorphisms) of the native alpine plant *Erythranthe (Mimulus) lewisii* to verify this hypothesis. - **Changes in Genetic Diversity**: The study also focuses on whether genetic diversity decreases and genetic differentiation increases during the history of glacier retreat. #### Hypotheses - **Dispersal Limitation Hypothesis**: If dispersal is limited during range expansion, it is expected to observe isolation-by-chronodistance, i.e., genetic diversity gradually decreases and genetic differentiation gradually increases over time. - **No Dispersal Limitation Hypothesis**: If dispersal is not limited, isolation-by-chronodistance will not be observed, and genetic diversity and genetic differentiation will not show a significant negative correlation trend. ### Methods - **Study System**: *Erythranthe lewisii* was chosen as the study subject because it is an early colonizer of disturbed alpine stream and river environments. - **Sampling Locations**: Sampling was conducted at two different glacier forelands (Helm and Garibaldi/Lava) in Garibaldi Provincial Park, British Columbia, Canada. - **Genomic Analysis**: Modern sequencing methods (such as ddRADseq) were used to generate datasets containing thousands of genetic markers to detect differences in genetic diversity. ### Results - **Population Structure**: Principal Component Analysis (PCA) showed that individuals from different glacier forelands clustered into different groups, indicating some genetic differentiation. - **Changes in Genetic Diversity**: No evidence was found to support a decrease in genetic diversity over time, suggesting that dispersal limitation may not be a major factor in these rapid range expansion processes. ### Conclusion - **Weak Support for Dispersal Limitation**: The study results weakly support the hypothesis that dispersal limitation plays a role in range expansion following glacier retreat but do not support the prediction of reduced genetic diversity. - **Applicability of Expansion Load**: This implies that on these spatial and temporal scales, the accumulation of expansion load may not be applicable, thus having a smaller impact on the adaptability of alpine species during range expansion.