Abstract:Heritable genetic versus non-heritable plastic phenotypic variation determine how selection may shape evolutionary responses. Population genomic studies typically aim to identify associations between loci (SNPs) and phenotypes, missing broader insight into heritable basis of polygenic traits with quantitative genomic approaches. Genomic animal models can facilitate estimates of trait heritability from genomic data but can be challenging to apply to wild organisms. This is because the populations of many wild organisms are large, comprising many distantly related individuals, which makes the sampling close-kin unlikely. This in turn limits the variation of relatedness in a sample, reducing the efficacy of genomic animal models. We developed a novel framework for applying genomic animal models to wild organisms where sampling close-kin may be near impossible. Our framework combines resampling of genetic markers with simulating different levels of heritability to infer the power and reliability of genomic animal models fitted to datasets lacking kin structure. We use our framework to estimate heritability of head shape traits in a wild marine intertidal fish, Bathygobius cocosensis (Bleeker 1854), using ddRAD SNP genotypes and phenotypes measured using geometric morphometric methods. In its eastern Australian range, B. cocosensis is highly abundant, has high effective gene flow, and occupies diverse habitats and microhabitats. Placing our observed genomic animal model results in the context of simulated results, we conclude that two of the head shape traits were heritable (estimated h2 = 0.26 and 0.18). This suggests that head shape phenotypes could evolve through heritable genetic changes in B. cocosensis, although there is likely a large non-heritable component. We also found strong phenotypic differentiation (pairwise PST ≤ 0.33) despite very weak genetic differentiation (pairwise FST < 0.002), suggesting that environmental factors might structure phenotypes amidst processes homogenising genetic variation. Our study addresses key methodological gaps for using quantitative genomic approaches on wild organisms, offering a rare example of partitioned heritable and non-heritable contributions to phenotypic variation in a non-model wild marine fish. This would have been difficult without our new framework to overcome the challenges of a dataset lacking kin structure.

Measurement and classification of bold-shy behaviours in medaka fish

Molecular basis of social competence in medaka fish

Interspecies Behavioral Variability of Medaka Fish Assessed by Comparative Phenomics

Is there a pace-of-life syndrome linking boldness and metabolic capacity for locomotion in bluegill sunfish?

Genomic and phenotypic characterisation of a wild Medaka population: Establishing an isogenic population genetic resource in fish

Characterizing medaka visual features using a high-throughput optomotor response assay

Statistical signature of subtle behavioural changes in large-scale behavioural assays

Boldness and exploratory behaviors differ between sunfish (Lepomis spp.) congeners in a standardized assay

Unravelling the origins of boldness behaviour: a common garden experiment with cavefish (Barbatula barbatula)

Chemical and Visual Cues as Modulators of the Stress Response to Social Isolation in the Marine Medaka, Oryzias melastigma

Identification of a Large Dataset of SNPs Inlarimichthys Polyactisusing High-Throughput 2B-Rad Sequencing

A novel framework for assessing the robustness of genomic animal models applied to a wild marine fish

Probabilistic modeling reveals coordinated social interaction states and their multisensory bases

Personality assessment protocol v2

Boldness Predicts Aggressiveness, Metabolism, and Activity in Black Rockfish Sebastes schlegelii

Cross-context behavioural correlations and signals of aggression in females of a livebearing fish

Personality assessment protocol v1

Consistent Individual Differences in Associative Learning Speed Are Not Linked to Boldness in Female Atlantic Mollies

Discrete modes of social information processing predict individual behavior of fish in a group

Basic knowledge of social hierarchies and physiological profile of reared sea bass Dicentrarchus labrax (L.)

Behavioural tactic predicts preoptic-hypothalamic gene expression more strongly than developmental morph in fish with alternative reproductive tactics