Abstract:Chemosensory science, the study of how organisms produce and assess olfactory information, is central to our understanding of how organisms interact and gain information about their environment. Signaling cue identification in aquatic systems lags behind our knowledge in terrestrial insects due to analytical challenges in aqueous environments. Unambiguous, reliable, and fast behavioral assays to evaluate the biological activity and function of a chemosensory cue are critical to understand aquatic signaling systems and enable research into their ecology, evolution, and threats in a changing environment. Yet, a range of anthropomorphic assumptions made in this research field create additional challenges to interpret data generated. Here, we evaluate common challenges including assumed readiness of individuals to respond, lack of information on the animals' physiological and social status, their pre-experimental cue exposure, the innate or learned character of the responses, the animals' acclimation and habituation status, and the impact of the animals upon their own environment. These factors lead to significant variability in animals' responses in bioassays, both in the field and in laboratory setups. In the light of our limited knowledge of aquatic chemosensory cues' chemical structure, active concentrations in samples, and undetermined response thresholds, we evaluate methods of mitigation to minimize differences between studies. We conclude that currently it is nearly impossible to compare results from chemosensory behavioral studies undertaken in different ecosystems, laboratories, and time points. There is an urgent need for the standardization of behavioral methods, recording of environmental conditions, and individuals' physiology, physical, and social status, to avoid conflicting and contradicting results when comparing studies. Including these parameters in experimental design and data interpretation will provide a deeper understanding of chemosensory communication, reduce unconscious bias in studies, and can help to explain the substantial individuality in animals' responses to chemosensory cues and their acclimation to environmental stress.

Chemical and Visual Cues as Modulators of the Stress Response to Social Isolation in the Marine Medaka, Oryzias melastigma

Physiological changes in response to social isolation in male medaka fish

Heart and shoal: Social cues and oxytocin receptors impact stress recovery in the zebrafish

Effects of single and repeated heat stress on anxiety-like behavior and locomotor activity in medaka fish

Molecular basis of social competence in medaka fish

Social isolation modulates appetite and avoidance behavior via a common oxytocinergic circuit in larval zebrafish

Stress produces negative judgement bias in cuttlefish

Interspecies Behavioral Variability of Medaka Fish Assessed by Comparative Phenomics

Does visual or mechanosensory disruption influence risk assessment in coral reef fishes: a preliminary study

Damsels in Distress: Oil Exposure Modifies Behavior and Olfaction in Bicolor Damselfish (Stegastes partitus)

Social isolation reduces metabolic rate and social preference in Wild-type Zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Emotional behavior in aquatic organisms? Lessons from crayfish and zebrafish

Bioassay complexities—exploring challenges in aquatic chemosensory research

Molecular plasticity to ocean warming and habitat loss in a coral reef fish

Oxytocin-mediated social preference and socially reinforced reward learning in the miniature fish Danionella cerebrum

Transcriptomic Analysis in Marine Medaka Gill Reveals That the Hypo-Osmotic Stress Could Alter the Immune Response Via the IL17 Signaling Pathway

Response to Conspecific Chemical Cues in Surface- and Cave-Dwelling Populations of Atlantic Mollies, Poecilia Mexicana

Molecular Staging of Marine Medaka: a Model Organism for Marine Ecotoxicity Study.

RNA-seq Analyses of Marine Medaka (oryzias Melastigma) Reveals Salinity Responsive Transcriptomes in the Gills and Livers.

Behavioral effects of visual stimuli in adult zebrafish using a novel eight-tank imaging system

Exploratory behaviour in the open field test adapted for larval zebrafish: impact of environmental complexity