Less Haste, More Speed: Does delayed blood culture loading lead to adverse incubation time or yield?

Gavin Deas,Fergus Hamilton,Philip Williams

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.10.15.24315399

2024-10-16

Abstract:Background Blood culture remains a vital diagnostic tool in the acutely unwell patient. The UK Standards for Microbiology Investigations (SMI) stipulate pre-analytical requirements that are aimed at increasing yield and reducing turnaround time. The requirement to load blood cultures onto incubators within 4 hours has shown to reduce turnaround time but limited evidence exists as to whether it improves yield. Methods We extracted blood culture results including organism growth, time to detection (TTD), location and time of sample collection from 4 hospitals in Southwest England. We then used mixed effects, Bayesian linear and logistic regression models to examine the effect of predictor variables like time to loading (TTL) on the response variable of growth or TTD. We used generalised additive models to explore non-linearity. Results 449,191 culture sets were analysed, 398,077 of which had enough data to include in the final analysis. 37,255 sets flagged positive (9.36%) of which 21,330 were considered pathogens. Our primary analysis identified a small decrease in yield with each hour delay in loading, OR 0.997 (95% credible interval, CrI 0.994; 1.001). This effect was largest in Streptococcus pneumoniae, agalactiae and pyogenes. In our analysis on TTD, culture sets spend 10.98 (95% CrI 7.8; 13.2) minutes less incubating for each hour delay. There was no convincing non-linearity in either of these effects. Conclusion There is a marginal loss of growth for every hour a blood culture is left unincubated, with the loss of recovery of Streptococcus pyogenes and other streptococci most common. There was no evidence of a reduction in Gram-negatives, anaerobes, or yeasts. There was a small decrease in TTD for delayed sets. This analysis suggests there is only marginal benefit in reducing time to load blood cultures on incubators.

Health Systems and Quality Improvement