Abstract:Dedicated long-term monitoring at appropriate spatial and temporal scales is necessary to understand biodiversity losses and develop effective conservation plans. Wildlife monitoring is often achieved by obtaining data at a combination of spatial scales, ranging from local to broad, to understand the status, trends, and drivers of individual species or whole communities and their dynamics. However, limited resources for monitoring necessitates tradeoffs in the scope and scale of data collection. Careful consideration of the spatial and temporal allocation of finite sampling effort is crucial for monitoring programs that span multiple spatial scales. Here we evaluate the ability of five monitoring designs-stratified random, weighted effort, indicator unit, rotating panel, and split panel-to recover parameter values that describe the status (occupancy), trends (change in occupancy), and drivers (spatially varying covariate and an autologistic term) of wildlife communities at two spatial scales. Using an amphibian monitoring program that spans a network of US national parks as a motivating example, we conducted a simulation study for a regional community occupancy sampling program to compare the monitoring designs across varying levels of sampling effort (ranging from 10% to 50%). We found that the stratified random design outperformed the other designs for most parameters of interest at both scales and was thus generally preferable in balancing the estimation of status, trends, and drivers across scales. However, we found that other designs had improved performance in specific situations. For example, the rotating panel design performed best at estimating spatial drivers at a regional level. Thus, our results highlight the nuanced scenarios in which various design strategies may be preferred and offer guidance as to how managers can balance common tradeoffs in large-scale and long-term monitoring programs in terms of the specific knowledge gained. Monitoring designs that improve accuracy in parameter estimates are needed to guide conservation policy and management decisions in the face of broad-scale environmental challenges, but the preferred design is sensitive to the specific objectives of a monitoring program.

Decision analysis shows scientific and economic value of community-based monitoring in Madagascar

An effective model for community-based conservation around authorized fishing settlements inside a devolved Wildlife Management Area in southern Tanzania

Socioeconomic impacts of small conserved sites on rural communities in Madagascar

The contribution of community-based conservation models to conserving large herbivore populations

Selecting umbrella species as mammal biodiversity indicators in tropical forest

Characteristics of participatory monitoring projects and their relationship to decision-making in biological resource management: a review

A comparison of monitoring designs to assess wildlife community parameters across spatial scales

Monitoring Spatiotemporal Changes in Land Use/Land Cover and its Impacts on Ecosystem Services in Southern Zambia

Measuring the Impact of Conservation: The Growing Importance of Monitoring Fauna, Flora and Funga

Long-term socio-environmental monitoring of protected areas is a persistent weak point in developing countries: Literature review and recommendations

Hunting indicators for community-led wildlife management in tropical Africa

Pan-Canadian review of community-based monitoring projects and their capacity to enhance environmental monitoring programs for cumulative effects assessments

Efficiency and concordance of alternative methods for minimizing opportunity costs in conservation planning

Assessing natural resource use by forest-reliant communities in Madagascar using functional diversity and functional redundancy metrics

Designing Monitoring Programs for Marine Protected Areas Within an Evidence Based Decision Making Paradigm

A landscape-scale assessment of tropical mammals reveals the effects of habitat and anthropogenic disturbance on community occupancy

Assessing the value of citizen scientist observations in tracking the abundance of marine fishes

Community-based monitoring reveals low anthropogenic pressure on a game vertebrate population in a sustainable-use Amazonian protected area

Perceived barriers to and drivers of community participation in protected-area governance

Modelling areas for sustainable forest management in a mining and human dominated landscape: A Geographical Information System (GIS)- Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) approach

Estimating the economic benefits and costs of highly‐protected marine protected areas