Rest-Activity Rhythm Phenotypes in Adults with Epilepsy and Intellectual Disability

Nandani Adhyapak,Mark A Abboud,Grace E Cardenas,Vaishnav Krishnan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.09.24313145
2024-09-10
Abstract:Objective: Sleep and rest-activity rhythms (RARs) are perturbed in many forms of neuropsychiatric illness. In this study, we applied wrist actigraphy to describe the extent of RAR perturbations in adults with epilepsy and intellectual disability (E+ID). We examined whether RAR phenotypes obtained cross-sectionally correlate with epilepsy severity, deficits in adaptive function and/or comorbid psychopathology. Methods: Primary caregivers of E+ID adults provided informed consent during routine ambulatory clinic visits and were asked to complete standardized surveys of overall epilepsy severity (GASE, Global Assessment of Severity of Epilepsy), adaptive function (ABAS-3, Adaptive Behavior Assessment System-3) and psychopathology (ABCL, Adult Behavior Checklist). Caregivers were also asked to ensure that subjects wore an Actiwatch-2 device continuously on their nondominant wrist for at least ten days. From recorded actograms, we calculated RAR amplitude, acrophase, robustness, intradaily variability (IV), interdaily stability (IS) and estimates of sleep quantity and timing. We compared these RAR metrics against those from (i) a previously published cohort of adults with epilepsy without ID (EID), and (ii) a cohort of age- and sex-matched intellectually able subjects measured within the Study of Latinos (SOL) Ancillary actigraphy study (SOL). Within E+ID subjects, we applied k-means analysis to divide subjects into three actigraphically distinct clusters. Results: 46 E+ID subjects (median age 26 [20-68], 47% female) provided a median recording duration of 11 days [range 6-27]. Surveys reflected low to extremely low levels of adaptive function (ABAS3 General Adaptive Composite score: median 50 [49-75]), and low/subclinical levels of psychopathology (ABCL total score: median 54.5 [25-67]). Compared with E-ID (n=57) and SOL (n=156) cohorts, E+ID subjects displayed significantly lower RAR amplitude, robustness and IS, with significantly higher IV and total daily sleep. K-means clustering of E+ID subjects recognized an intermediate cluster B, with RAR values indistinguishable to E-ID. Cluster A subjects displayed pronounced hypoactivity and hypersomnia with high rates of rhythm fragmentation, while cluster C subjects featured hyper-robust and high amplitude RARs. All three clusters were similar in age, body mass index, antiseizure medication (ASM) polytherapy, ABAS3 and ABCL scores. We qualitatively describe RAR examples from all three clusters. Interpretation: We show that adults with epilepsy and intellectual disability display a wide spectrum of RAR phenotypes that do not neatly correlate with measures of adaptive function or epilepsy severity. Prospective studies are necessary to determine whether continuous actigraphic monitoring can sensitively capture changes in chronobiological health that may arise with disease progression, iatrogenesis (e.g., ASM toxicity) or acute health deteriorations (e.g., seizure exacerbation, pneumonia). Similar long-term data is necessary to recognize whether behavioral interventions targeted to normalize RARs may promote improvements in adaptive function and therapy engagement.
Neurology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: in adult patients with epilepsy and intellectual disability (E+ID), the abnormal manifestations of sleep and activity rhythms (RARs) and their relationships with the severity of epilepsy, adaptive function deficits and/or comorbid psychopathology. Specifically, the researchers applied wrist actigraphy to describe the degree of perturbation of RAR in E+ID adults and to explore whether these RAR phenotypes are related to the severity of epilepsy, deficits in adaptive function and comorbid psychopathology. ### Main research questions: 1. **Degree of perturbation of RARs**: The researchers hope to evaluate the perturbation of RAR in E+ID adults through wrist actigraphy, including the amplitude of RAR, peak time, stability, intraday variability (IV), inter - day stability (IS), and the amount and time of sleep. 2. **Comparison with the control group**: Compare the RAR parameters of E+ID patients with two control groups, one is epilepsy patients without intellectual disability (E - ID), and the other is age - and gender - matched normal - intelligence adults (SOL). 3. **Heterogeneity of RAR phenotypes**: Identify different RAR phenotypes in E+ID patients and explore whether these phenotypes are related to adaptive function or psychopathology scores. ### Research background: - **Challenges of E+ID**: E+ID patients face more challenges in epilepsy management, such as limitations in language and cognitive functions, high - frequency side effects of ASM, dysphagia, etc. - **Importance of RAR**: Abnormal RAR may be related to multiple neuropsychiatric diseases, but at present, little is known about the specific manifestations of RAR in E+ID patients. ### Research methods: - **Data collection**: Collect activity data of E+ID patients through wrist actigraphy for at least 10 days. - **Questionnaire survey**: Collect information on the severity of epilepsy (GASE), adaptive function (ABAS - 3) and psychopathology (ABCL). - **Data analysis**: Use k - means clustering analysis to divide E+ID patients into three different RAR phenotype groups. ### Research results: - **Differences in RAR parameters**: The RAR amplitude, stability and IS of E+ID patients are significantly lower than those of the E - ID and SOL groups, while the IV and total sleep time are significantly higher than those of these two control groups. - **Heterogeneity of RAR phenotypes**: Three different RAR phenotype groups are identified in E+ID patients. Each group has different RAR characteristics, but the adaptive function and psychopathology scores are similar. ### Conclusions: - **Wide variation of RAR**: E+ID patients show a wide range of RAR phenotypes, and the relationship between these phenotypes and adaptive function or the severity of epilepsy is not obvious. - **Future research directions**: Further prospective studies are needed to determine whether continuous activity records can sensitively capture circadian rhythm changes caused by disease progression, drug toxicity or acute health deterioration (such as aggravated epilepsy, pneumonia). Long - term data are also helpful to evaluate whether behavioral interventions targeting "normalized" RAR can improve adaptive function and treatment participation. Through this study, the author hopes to provide new biomarkers for the clinical management and treatment of E+ID patients, so as to better understand and support the health needs of this special population.