Does slow oscillation-spindle coupling contribute to sleep-dependent memory consolidation? A Bayesian meta-analysis

Thea Ng,Eunsol Noh,Rebecca M. C. Spencer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.08.28.610060
2024-08-29
Abstract:The active system consolidation theory suggests that information transfer between the hippocampus and cortex during sleep underlies memory consolidation. Neural oscillations during sleep, including the temporal coupling between slow oscillations (SO) and sleep spindles (SP), may play a mechanistic role in memory consolidation. However, differences in analytical approaches and the presence of physiological and behavioral moderators have led to inconsistent conclusions. This meta-analysis, comprising 23 studies and 297 effect sizes, focused on four standard phase-amplitude coupling measures including coupling phase, strength, percentage, and SP amplitude, and their relationship with memory retention. We developed a standardized approach to incorporate non-normal circular- linear correlations. We found strong evidence supporting that precise and strong SO-fast SP coupling in the frontal lobe predicts memory consolidation. The strength of this association is mediated by memory type, aging, and dynamic spatio-temporal features, including SP frequency and cortical topography. In conclusion, SO-SP coupling should be considered as a general physiological mechanism for memory consolidation.
Neuroscience
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether slow - wave oscillation - sleep spindle wave coupling (SO - SP coupling) contributes to sleep - dependent memory consolidation. Specifically, through the Bayesian meta - analysis method, the author explored how the cross - frequency coupling between slow - wave oscillation and sleep spindle wave affects memory retention and determined which specific SO - SP coupling measurement indicators can most accurately predict memory retention performance. In addition, the paper also analyzed how physiological and behavioral factors regulate the strength of the relationship between SO - SP coupling and memory consolidation. ### Research Background - **Active System Consolidation Theory**: This theory holds that during sleep, the information transfer between the hippocampus and the cerebral cortex is the basis for memory consolidation. Neural oscillations, especially the temporal coupling of slow - wave oscillation (SO) and sleep spindle wave (SP), may play a mechanistic role in memory consolidation. - **Research Challenges**: Due to differences in analysis methods and the existence of physiological and behavioral regulatory factors, research conclusions are inconsistent. Therefore, a systematic meta - analysis is required to integrate existing research results and propose standardized research and analysis methods. ### Research Objectives - **Primary Objective**: Through the Bayesian hierarchical model, evaluate the relationship between the phase - amplitude coupling (PAC) of SO - SP coupling and memory retention, and determine which specific PAC measurement indicators can best predict memory retention. - **Secondary Objective**: Through moderator analysis, understand how physiological and behavioral factors affect the strength of the relationship between SO - SP coupling and memory consolidation. Specifically, five moderator questions are proposed: 1. Is SO - SP coupling a general physiological mechanism for memory consolidation or is it specific to certain types of memory? 2. How do development and aging affect the association between coupling and memory consolidation? 3. Is the coupling detected in specific (functional) regions more indicative of memory retention? 4. In which frequency range is SP coupling more likely to be related to memory consolidation? 5. Do sleep stages and sleep cycles affect the measurement of the coupling - memory association? ### Research Methods - **Data Sources**: Including 23 studies, with a total of 297 effect sizes. - **Analysis Methods**: Use the Bayesian hierarchical model to analyze the relationship between four standard phase - amplitude coupling measurement indicators (coupling phase, intensity, percentage, and SP amplitude) and memory retention. - **Moderator Analysis**: Consider the influence of factors such as memory type, age, SP type, PSG channel, sleep stage, and sleep cycle. ### Main Findings - **Overall Model**: Without considering regulatory factors, there is a small but very strong and consistent association between the preferred phase of SO - SP coupling and memory consolidation, Zrpooled = 0.07 [0.01, 0.13], BF10 = 58.35, probability = 0.98. - **Moderator Analysis**: - **Memory Task**: The association between memory retention in spatial tasks and the SO - SP coupling phase is significantly lower than that in motor tasks. - **Age**: As age increases, the association between the SO - SP coupling phase and memory retention weakens significantly. - **SP Frequency**: The association between fast SP (fast SP) and memory retention is stronger than that of slow SP (slow SP). - **PSG Channel**: The coupling phase of the prefrontal electrode cluster has the strongest association with memory retention. - **Sleep Stages and Sleep Cycles**: These factors have a weak influence on the association between the SO - SP coupling phase and memory retention. ### Conclusions - **SO - SP Coupling**: Should be regarded as a general physiological mechanism for memory consolidation, especially the precise and strong coupling in the prefrontal area. - **Regulatory Factors**: Factors such as memory type, age, SP frequency, and PSG channel significantly affect the strength of the relationship between SO - SP coupling and memory consolidation. ### Future Research Directions - **Standardized Research**: Propose standardized research and analysis methods to reduce methodological differences and improve the reproducibility of research. - **Clinical Applications**: Explore the potential applications of SO - SP coupling in memory disorders and cognitive decline.