High-Field 7T MRI in a drug-resistant paediatric epilepsy cohort: image comparison and radiological outcomes

Katy Vecchiato,Chiara Casella,Ayse Sila Dokumaci,Olivia Carney,Jon O. Cleary,Pierluigi Di Ciò,Michela Cleri,Kathleen Colford,Rory J. Piper,Tomoki Arichi Arichi,Michael Eyre,Fraser Aitken,Raphael Tomi-Tricot,Tom Wilkinson,Colm J. McGinnity,Sharon L. Giles,Shaihan Malik,Alexander Hammers,Philippa Bridgen,David W Carmichael,Jonathan O'Muircheartaigh
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.08.19.24312117
2024-08-23
Abstract:Background and Objectives: Epileptogenic lesions in focal epilepsy can be subtle or undetected on conventional brain MRI. Ultra-high field (7T) MRI offers higher spatial resolution, contrast and signal-to-noise ratio compared to conventional imaging systems and has shown promise in the pre-surgical evaluation of adult focal epilepsy. However, the utility of ultra-high field MRI in paediatric focal epilepsy, where malformations of cortical development are more common, is unclear. This study compared 7T to conventional 3T MRI in children with epilepsy by comparing: (i) scan tolerability; (ii) radiological image quality; (iii) lesion yield. Materials and Methods: Children with drug-resistant focal epilepsy and healthy controls were recruited prospectively and imaged at both 3T and 7T. Safety and tolerability during scanning was assessed via a questionnaire. Image quality was evaluated by an expert paediatric neuroradiologist and estimated quantitatively by comparing cortical thickness between field strengths. To assess lesion detection yield of 7T MRI, a multi-disciplinary team jointly reviewed patients' images. Results: 41 patients (8-17 years, mean=12.6 years, 22 male) and 22 healthy controls (8-17 years, mean=11.7 years, 15 male) were recruited. All children completed the scan, with no significant adverse events. Higher discomfort due to dizziness was reported at 7T (p=0.02), with side-effects more frequently noted in younger children (p=0.02). However, both field strengths were generally well-tolerated and side-effects were transient. 7T images had increased inhomogeneity and artefacts compared to those obtained at 3T. Cortical thickness measurements were significantly thinner at 7T (p<0.001). 8/26 (31%) patients had new lesions identified at 7T which were not identified at 3T, influencing the surgical management in 4/26 (15%). Discussion: 7T MRI in children with epilepsy is feasible, well-tolerated and is associated with a 31% improvement in lesion detection rates.
Radiology and Imaging
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to explore the application of ultra-high field strength (7 Tesla, 7T) magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in drug-resistant pediatric focal epilepsy. Specifically, the study attempts to address the following issues: 1. **Scan Tolerance and Safety**: Evaluate the tolerance and safety of 7T MRI in children, including discomfort and side effects during the scanning process. 2. **Image Quality**: Compare the image quality differences between 7T MRI and conventional 3T MRI, particularly in the measurement of cortical thickness. 3. **Lesion Detection Rate**: Assess the effectiveness of 7T MRI in detecting lesions related to focal epilepsy, especially in patients where 3T MRI failed to identify lesions. ### Background and Purpose - **Background**: Focal epilepsy is a common neurological disorder, with about 40% of patients being resistant to drug treatment. Surgical resection of epileptogenic tissue can significantly reduce or eliminate seizures, but this requires accurate identification of the epileptogenic focus. Traditional 1.5T or 3T MRI can sometimes fail to detect subtle structural abnormalities, which are more common and harder to identify in children. - **Purpose**: By comparing 7T MRI and 3T MRI, evaluate the application value of 7T MRI in drug-resistant pediatric focal epilepsy, including its performance in scan tolerance, image quality, and lesion detection rate. ### Methods - **Participants**: 41 children with drug-resistant focal epilepsy and 22 healthy control children were recruited. - **Data Collection**: All participants underwent scans on both 3T and 7T MRI systems, including T1-weighted, FLAIR, and T2-weighted sequences. - **Analysis**: - **Safety and Tolerance**: Assess participants' comfort and side effects through questionnaires. - **Cortical Thickness Quantitative Assessment**: Use the Human Connectome Project (HCP) structural pipeline for cortical surface reconstruction and cortical thickness calculation. - **Radiological Image Quality Assessment**: Evaluate the quality of 3T and 7T MRI images by expert pediatric neuroradiologists. - **Clinical Value**: A multidisciplinary team jointly reviews the patients' imaging data to assess the clinical value of 7T MRI in lesion detection. ### Results - **Participants**: A total of 63 children were recruited, including 41 children with drug-resistant focal epilepsy and 22 healthy control children. - **Safety and Tolerance**: 7T MRI was generally well tolerated, with the main discomforts being neck pain, ear pain, and transient dizziness. The report rate of dizziness for 7T MRI was significantly higher than for 3T MRI, but all were temporary. - **Cortical Thickness Quantitative Assessment**: The cortical thickness measured by 7T MRI was significantly lower than that measured by 3T MRI, especially in the temporoparietal/sensory regions. - **Radiological Image Quality Assessment**: The image quality of 3T MRI was very good, while the overall image quality of 7T MRI was good, but with some signal loss and motion artifacts. - **Clinical Value**: The lesion detection rate of 7T MRI significantly increased from 35% with 3T to 55%, with new lesions found in 8 patients where 3T MRI had not detected any. These new findings impacted the surgical management of 4 patients. ### Discussion - **Conclusion**: 7T MRI is feasible in drug-resistant pediatric focal epilepsy, with good tolerance and a significant increase in lesion detection rate, aiding in improved surgical planning and clinical decision-making. - **Significance**: The application of 7T MRI in pediatric focal epilepsy has important clinical value, especially in patients where traditional MRI failed to detect lesions. However, the image quality and tolerance of 7T MRI still need further optimization.