Abstract:Reward-motivated memory has been studied extensively in psychology and neuroscience. Most studies follow the same type of paradigm: stimuli are cued at encoding with high or low reward values which indicate the amount the stimulus is worth if successfully remembered on a subsequent memory test, usually recognition. Each incorrect endorsement of a lure at retrieval is penalized with an arbitrary value between the high and low reward value, resulting in a single false alarm rate. Studies employing this type of paradigm have reported higher hit rates for high value items compared to low value items, but generally hit rate is the only measure of memory that is reported as a function of reward value. This leaves open the possibility that high reward items have a higher hit rate because participants are more willing to endorse those items as “old”, due to biases in the reward structure of these paradigms. Other measures, like discriminability and response bias, are overlooked when there is only a single false alarm rate, but we hypothesize that these other measures are also susceptible to motivational manipulations. To test whether reward motivation influences these other factors, we created a novel paradigm that associated rewards with categories (indoor vs. outdoor scenes), allowing for a separate false alarm rate as well as hit rate at each level of reward. We report results of three experiments that varied when reward cues were introduced and the penalties associated with false alarms for the categorized items. We replicated prior findings of higher hit rates for high compared to low reward items, but consistently across three experiments, when d’ was calculated, we found no difference in memory discriminability as a function of reward. Further, in two experiments we found that response bias was more conservative for low reward items: participants were more likely to endorse a “new” response to low compared to high reward items. This latter effect of reward on response bias did not occur when the amount of the false alarm penalty matched the possible reward. Our findings reveal that reward motivation influences memory, but also decisional biases thought to be independent of memory processes. The amount of both the reward value of the target items, and the amount of the false alarm penalty should be considered when designing experimental paradigms to study motivation-cognition interactions.

Successful retrieval is its own reward

Effort provides its own reward: endeavors reinforce subjective expectation and evaluation of task performance

Memory for rewards guides retrieval

Retrieval Success is Accompanied by Enhanced Activation in Anterior Prefrontal Cortex During Recognition Memory: An Event-Related fMRI Study

Neural correlates of retrieval-based memory enhancement: An fMRI study of the testing effect

Reward Motivation Influences Response Bias on a Recognition Memory Task

Intrinsic monitoring of learning success facilitates memory encoding via the activation of the SN/VTA-Hippocampal loop

Curiosity Satisfaction Increases Event-related Potentials Sensitive to Reward

Selective retrieval revealed by electroencephalographic (EEG) neural pattern reinstatement

Neural Correlates of Long-Term Memory Enhancement Following Retrieval Practice

Top-down task goals induce the retrieval state

The neural basis of attentional selection in goal-directed memory retrieval

Response-locked theta dissociations reveal potential feedback signal following successful retrieval

Remembering pleasure and personal meaning from episodes of intrinsic motivation: an fMRI study

The affective response to positive performance feedback is associated with motor learning

Memory of my victory and your defeat: Contributions of reward- and memory-related regions to the encoding of winning events in competitions with others

To Reveal or Not to Reveal? Observation of Social Outcomes Facilitates Reward Processing

The persistence of memory: prior memory responses modulate behavior and brain state engagement

Remembering what is relevant: how is goal-directed memory reactivation supported by attentional selection?

A Dual Reward-Place Association Task to Study the Preferential Retention of Relevant Memories in Rats

Neural activity ramps in frontal cortex signal extended motivation during learning