The Relationship between Noise Pollution and Depression and Implications for Healthy Ageing: A Spatial Analysis Using Routinely Collected Primary Care Data

Dialechti Tsimpida,Anastasia Tsakiridi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.15.24310019

2024-07-15

Abstract:Environmental noise is a significant public health concern, ranking among the top environmental risks to citizens' health and quality of life. Despite various studies exploring the effects of atmospheric pollution on mental health, spatial investigations into the effects of noise pollution have been notably absent. This study addresses this gap by investigating the association between noise pollution (from road and rail networks) and depression for the first time in England, and first explores localised patterns based on area deprivation. Depression prevalence, defined as the percentage of patients with a recorded depression diagnosis, was calculated in small areas within Cheshire and Merseyside ICS using the Quality and Outcomes Framework Indicators dataset for 2019. Strategic noise mapping for rail and road noise (LDEN) was employed to quantify noise pollution, indicating a 24-hour annual average noise level with distinct weightings for evening and night periods. The English Index of Multiple Deprivation (IMD) was utilised to represent neighbourhood deprivation. Geographical Weighted Regression and Generalised Structural Equation Spatial Modelling (GSESM) were applied to estimate relationships between transportation noise, depression prevalence, and IMD at the Lower Super Output Area (LSOA) level. While transportation noise showed a low direct effect on depression levels in Cheshire and Merseyside ICS, it significantly mediated other factors linked to depression prevalence. Notably, GSESM revealed that health deprivation and disability was strongly associated (0.62) with depression through the indirect effect of environmental noise, particularly where transportation noise exceeds 55 dB on a 24-hour basis. Comprehending variations in noise exposure across different areas is paramount. This research not only provides valuable insights for informed decision-making but also lays the groundwork for implementing noise mitigation measures. These measures are aimed at addressing mental health inequalities, enhancing the quality of life for the exposed population and supporting a healthier ageing process in urban environments. The findings also carry crucial implications for public health, specifically in tailoring targeted interventions to mitigate noise-related health risks in areas where noise burdens exceed 55 dB, and residents may experience health deprivation and disability.

Public and Global Health

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper explores the relationship between noise pollution and depression and its impact on healthy aging, with a specific focus on the association between traffic noise (from road and rail networks) and depression in England, and analyzes local patterns under conditions of regional deprivation. The study uses strategic noise map data to quantify noise pollution, calculates the 24-hour average noise levels, and estimates the relationship between traffic noise, depression incidence rate, and the Index of Multiple Deprivation (IMD) through geographically weighted regression and general structural equation spatial modeling.

The study found that although the direct effect of traffic noise on depression levels is relatively low in Cheshire and Merseyside, it significantly mediates other factors related to depression, particularly when traffic noise exceeds 55 decibels, there is a strong association between health deprivation, disability, and depression. The study highlights the importance of understanding differences in noise exposure in different regions, providing a basis for developing noise reduction measures to reduce mental health inequalities, improve residents' quality of life, and promote healthy aging in urban environments.

In addition, the paper points out that although there have been many studies exploring the impact of the environment on mental health, there is relatively little research on the impact of noise pollution on mental health, especially in the UK. The research findings are of significant importance in formulating targeted interventions for noise-related health risks, particularly in areas where noise burden exceeds 55 decibels.