: A general mechanistic framework of within-host parasite competition

Ashwini Ramesh,Spencer Ryan Hall

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.06.28.24309686

2024-07-05

Abstract:Coinfections pose serious threats to health and exacerbate parasite burden. If coinfection is detrimental, then what within-host factors facilitate it? Equally importantly, what hinders it, say via exclusion or priority effects? Such interactions ought to stem from their within-host environment i.e., resources that parasites steal from hosts and immune cells that kill them. Yet, despite two decades of empirical focus on within-host infection dynamics, we lack a mechanistic framework to understand why coinfection arises and the diverse range of its consequences. Hence, we construct a trait-based niche framework, one that illustrates general principles that govern parasite competition for a resource and apparent competition for immune cells. We show that coinfection requires a competition-resistance tradeoff and that each parasite most impacts the niche factor to which it is most sensitive. These predictions then provide mechanistic interpretation for infection outcomes seen in a variety of extant experiments: Why does nutrient supplementation shift relative frequencies of coinfecting parasites? When and how does sequence of parasite invasion allow only early invading parasites to win? How does intrinsic variation in immune response shape coinfection burden? Together, this mechanistic framework of parasite competition offers new biomedical perspectives to better predict within-host infection dynamics and improve individual health.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are related to the causes and consequences of coinfection in the host. Specifically, the paper focuses on:

1. **Mechanisms of coinfection occurrence**: If coinfection is harmful to the host, what factors in the host promote coinfection? Equally important, what factors can prevent coinfection, for example, through exclusion or priority effects?

2. **Diversity of coinfection consequences**: Why does coinfection produce diverse consequences? How are these consequences affected by the internal environment of the host, especially the role of resources (such as nutrients) and immune cells?

To answer these questions, the paper constructs a trait - based niche framework, which explains the general principles of parasites competing for resources and immune cells in the host. The main contributions of the paper include:

- **Competition - resistance trade - off**: Coinfection requires a competition - resistance trade - off among parasites, that is, one parasite has an advantage in resource competition but is more vulnerable to immune attacks.

- **Resource sensitivity**: Each parasite has the greatest impact on the niche factor (resource or immune cell) to which it is most sensitive.

- **Mechanistic explanation of experimental results**: These predictions provide a mechanistic explanation for the infection results observed in existing experiments, such as:
- How does nutrient supplementation change the relative frequencies of coinfecting parasites?
- When and how does the order of parasite invasion lead to the victory of the early invader?
- How does the inherent variation in the immune response affect the coinfection burden?

Through this mechanistic framework, the paper provides a new perspective for better predicting infection dynamics in the host and improving individual health.