Dose-dependent interaction of parasites with tiers of host defense predicts "wormholes" that prolong infection at intermediate inoculum sizes
Andrea L. Graham,Roland R. Regoes
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1012652
2024-12-08
PLoS Computational Biology
Abstract:Immune responses are induced by parasite exposure and can in turn reduce parasite burden. Despite such apparently simple rules of engagement, key drivers of within-host dynamics, including dose-dependence of defense and infection duration, have proven difficult to predict. Here, we model how varied inoculating doses interact with multi-tiered host defenses at a site of inoculation, by confronting barrier, innate, and adaptive tiers with replicating and non-replicating parasites across multiple orders of magnitude of dose. We find that, in general, intermediate parasite doses generate infections of longest duration because they are sufficient in number to breach barrier defenses, but insufficient to strongly induce subsequent tiers of defense. These doses reveal "wormholes" in defense from which parasites might profit: Deviation from the hypothesis of independent action, which postulates that each parasite has an independent probability of establishing infection, may therefore be widespread. Interestingly, our model predicts local maxima of duration at two doses–one for each tier transition. While some empirical evidence is consistent with nonlinear dose-dependencies, testing the predicted dynamics will require finer-scale dose variation than experiments usually incorporate. Our results help explain varied infection establishment and duration among differentially-exposed hosts and elucidate evolutionary pressures that shape both virulence and defense. Organisms vary in their exposure to parasites and pathogens, such that some individuals breathe in, ingest, or are inoculated (e.g., by insect vectors) with just a few parasites, while others are confronted with large doses. This variation in inoculating dose is likely to affect the odds of successful defense and the duration of infection. For example, individuals confronted with very few parasites might be completely defended, such that infection never establishes. Intuitive though such predictions are, the dose-dependence of the establishment and duration of infection is poorly understood. Here, we use a mathematical model of the three known tiers of immune defenses–i.e., barrier, innate, and adaptive tiers–to investigate how varied inoculating doses interact with immune systems. We find that although the lowest doses are indeed readily controlled, the highest doses induce potent immune responses that curtail infection. As a result, intermediate doses are the ones that can slip past barrier defense yet under the radar of induced defenses. Intermediate doses therefore generate infections of greatest duration. These findings help explain why hosts vary so much in the course of infection and suggest new research directions in epidemiology and immunology.
biochemical research methods,mathematical & computational biology