A disorder of consciousness rather than complete locked-in may be the final stage of ALS

Florent GOBERT,Ines Merida,Emmanuel Maby,Perrine Seguin,Julien Jung,Dominique Morlet,Nathalie Andre-Obadia,Frederic Dailler,Christian Berthomier,Anatole Otman,didier Le-Bars,Christian Scheiber,Alexander Hammers,Emilien Bernard,Nicolas Costes,Romain Bouet,Jeremie Mattout

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.06.21.24307994

2024-06-24

Abstract:The end-stage of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis [ALS] is presumed to be a complete Locked-In Syndrome [cLIS], assuming an internally preserved consciousness that would not be accessible anymore from the outside. However, whether consciousness persists at this stage of ALS remains to be demonstrated. Shifting the perspective from cLIS (presupposed consciousness) to Cognitive Motor Dissociation (to-be-demonstrated consciousness), we attempted to demonstrate consciousness and communication with two cLIS-ALS patients using a multimodal awareness assessment battery. It involved complete neurophysiological assessments, passive and active auditory oddball paradigm (Subject-Own-Name/P300), an auditory-based Brain-Computer-Interface [BCI] and activation-task imaging using functional MRI or [15O]H2O PET. Wakefulness (long-term EEG), brain morphology (CT or MRI scans) and resting brain metabolism ([18F]fluoro-deoxy-glucose PET) were used to describe the underlying cLIS brain function. While Patient 1 could initially follow simple commands, he failed twice to control the BCI. At follow-up, he showed no more evidence of command following and his oddball (Own Name - P300) cognitive responses has disappeared. At his unique evaluation, Patient 2 was neither able to follow simple commands nor to control the BCI. Both patients had altered wakefulness, brain atrophy, and a global cortico-sub-cortical hypometabolism pattern compatible with a disorder of consciousness, regarded as an extreme form of an ALS-associated fronto-temporal dementia. While it is not possible to firmly demonstrate the absence of awareness, each independent measure concurred with suggesting that a degenerative disorder of consciousness rather than a cLIS might be the final stage of ALS. In future cass, this dramatic cognitive decline should be anticipated before communication disappears to enable precise advance directives regarding end-of-life issues in case complete, and neurophysiologically confirmed, unresponsiveness occurs. Altogether, the neuroimaging features distinguishing the mechanisms in this rare condition is a significant milestone to understand end-stage ALS. The present clinical study calls for further exploration of this terminal stage to determine the prevalence of this profile in whom communication seems hopeless.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the question of whether late-stage patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) still retain consciousness. Researchers attempted to assess the level of consciousness in two completely locked-in state (cLIS) ALS patients using various non-behavioral methods. Specifically, they employed a multimodal assessment battery (MAAB) that included brain-computer interface (BCI), auditory oddball paradigm (Subject-Own-Name/P300), auditory-based brain-computer interface, functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), or [15O]H2O positron emission tomography (PET) techniques.

The main findings of the study include:

1. **BCI control failure**: Both patients failed to achieve effective communication through BCI.
2. **Disappearance of passive and active evoked potential responses**: Patient 1 was able to follow simple commands during the initial test but failed in the subsequent two BCI tests; during follow-up, their P300 response to their own name also disappeared. Patient 2 was never able to follow simple commands or control the BCI.
3. **Abnormal sleep-wake patterns**: Long-term electroencephalogram (EEG) showed abnormal wakefulness fluctuations in both patients, differing from normal individuals and typical cLIS patients.
4. **Brain structure and metabolic changes**: Morphological scans showed brain atrophy, particularly in the frontal and temporal lobes. PET scans revealed a global hypometabolic pattern in subcortical areas and the thalamus, consistent with impaired consciousness.

In summary, the study results suggest that in late-stage ALS, there may be a "degenerative consciousness disorder" rather than the traditional completely locked-in state (cLIS). This state can be seen as an extreme form of ALS-related frontotemporal dementia (FTD). Although it cannot be absolutely proven that consciousness is absent, all independent measurements consistently point to this conclusion. The study emphasizes the importance of considering and clarifying end-of-life care issues before complete loss of communication ability and calls for further exploration of the prevalence of this terminal state.