Research considerations for prospective studies of patients with coma and disorders of consciousness
Lorenzo Tinti,Thomas Lawson,Erika Molteni,Daniel Kondziella,Verena Rass,Tarek Sharshar,Yelena G Bodien,Joseph T Giacino,Stephan A Mayer,Moshgan Amiri,Susanne Muehlschlegel,Chethan P Venkatasubba Rao,Paul M Vespa,David K Menon,Giuseppe Citerio,Raimund Helbok,Molly McNett,Curing Coma Campaign Collaborators,Sachin Agarwal,Venkatesh Aiyagari,Yama Akbari,Asher Albertson,Sheila Alexander,Anne Alexandrov,Ayham Alkhachroum,Fawaz Al-Mufti,Moshagan Amiri,Brian Appavu,Meron Awraris Gebrewold,Marc Ayounb,Rafael Badenes,Mary Kay Bader,Neeraj Badjiata,Ram Balu,Brooke Barlow,Megan Barra,Rachel Beekman,Ettore Beghi,Erta Beqiri,Tracey Berlin,Federico Bilotta,Thomas Bleck,Yelena Bodien,Varina Boerwinkle,Melanie Boly,Alexandra Bonnel,Luca Brazzi,Emery Brown,Sebina Bulic,Eder Caceres,Adrian Caceres,Tullio Cafiero,Elizabeth Carroll,Emilio G Cediel,Sherry Chou,Jan Claassen,Chad Condie,Alfredo Conti,Katie Cosmas,Paolo Costa,Claire Creutzfeldt,Neha Dangayach,Mario Dauri,Derek Debicki,Michael DeGeorgia,Caroline Der-Nigoghossian,Masoom Desai,Rajat Dhar,Michael Diringer,Emily Durr,Brian Edlow,Ari Ercole,Anna Estraneo,Guido Falcone,Salia Farrokh,Adam Ferguson,Davinia Fernandez-Espejo,Ericka Fink,Joseph Fins,Brandon Foreman,Federico Franchi,Jennifer Frontera,Rishi Ganesan,Nicolas Gaspard,Ahmeneh Ghavam,Joseph Giacino,Christie Gibbons,Emily Gilmore,Chavie Glustein,Olivia Gosseries,Theresa Green,David Greer,Mary Guanci,Deepak Gupta,Cecil Hahn,Ryan Hakimi,Flora Hammond,Daniel F Hanley,Jed Hartings,Ahmed Hassan,Claude Hemphill,Arthur Henrique Galvão Bruno Da Cunha,Holly Hinson,Karen Hirsch,Sarah Hocker,Peter Hu,Xiao Hu,Theresa Human,David Hwang,Judy Illes,Matthew Jaffa,Michael L James,Anna Janas,Susan Johnson,Morgan Jones,Ralf J Jox,Atul Kalanuria,Emanuela Keller,Lori Kennedy,Megan Kennelly,Maggie Keogh,Jenn Kim,Keri Kim,Hannah Kirsch,Matthew Kirschen,Nerissa Ko,Natalie Kreitzer,Julie Kromm,Abhay Kumar,Pedro Kurtz,Steven Laureys,Nicolas Lejeune,Ariane Lewis,John Liang,Geoffrey Ling,Sarah Livesay,Andrea Luppi,Jennifer MacDonald,Craig Maddux,Dea Mahanes,Shraddha Mainali,Nelson Maldonado,Rennan Martins Ribeiro,Luciana Mascia,Marcello Massimini,Rohan Mathur,Stephan Mayer,Victoria McCredie,Jorge Mejia-Mantilla,Michael Mendoza,David Menon,Geert Meyfroidt,Julio Mijangos,Dick Moberg,Asma Moheet,Elisa Montalenti,Martin Monti,Chris Morrison,Marina Munar,Brooke Murtaugh,Lionel Naccache,Masao Nagayama,Emerson Nairon,Thomas Nakagawa,Andrea Naldi,Ganesalingam Narenthiran,Girija Natarajan,Esther Nemetsky,Virginia Newcombe,Niklas Nielsen,Naomi Niznick,Filipa Noronha-Falcão,Paul Nyquist,DaiWai Olson,Marwan Othman,Adrian Owen,Llewellyn Padayachy,Mehrnaz Pajoumand,Soojin Park,Melissa Pergakis,Heidi Perry,Len Polizzotto,Nader Pouratian,Marilyn Price Spivack,Lara Prisco,Javier Provencio,Francesco Puglises,Louis Puybasset,Chethan Rao,Lindsay Rasmussen,Frank Rasulo,Bappaditya Ray,Zaccaria Ricci,Risa Richardson,Cassia Righy Shinotsuka,Chiara Robba,Courtney Robertson,Benjamin Rohaut,John Rolston,Stefano Romagnoli,Mario Rosanova,Eric Rosenthal,Shaun Rowe,Michael Rubin,Mary Beth Russell,Gisele Sampaio Silva,Leandro Sanz,Simone Sarasso,Aarti Sarwal,Nicolas Schiff,Caroline Schnakers,David Seder,Vishank Arun Shah,Amy Shapiro-Rosenbaubm,Angela Shapshak,Kartavya Sharma,Kumar Ajay Sharma,Lori Shutter,Jacobo Sitt,Beth Slomine,Keaton Smetana,Peter Smielewski,Wade Smith,Emmanuel Stamatakis,Alexis Steinberg,Robert Stevens,Jose Suarez,Gene Sung,Bethany Sussman,Shaurya Taran,Anna Teresa Mazzeo,Aurore Thibaut,David Thompson,Zachary Threlkeld,Daniel Toker,Michel Torbey,Jenna Tosto,Stephen Trevick,Georgia Tsaousi,Alexis Turgeon,Andrew Udy,Panos Varelas,Paul Vespa,Walter Videtta,Henning Voss,Ford Vox,Amy Wagner,Sarah Wahlster,Mark Wainwright,John Whyte,Briana Witherspoon,Aleksandra Sasha Yakhkind,Susan Yeager,Michael Young,Sahar Zafar,Ross Zafonte,Darin Zahuranec,Chris Zammit,Bei Zhang,Wendy Ziai,Lara Zimmerman,Elizabeth Zink
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/braincomms/fcae022
2024-01-29
Abstract:Disorders of consciousness are neurological conditions characterized by impaired arousal and awareness of self and environment. Behavioural responses are absent or are present but fluctuate. Disorders of consciousness are commonly encountered as a consequence of both acute and chronic brain injuries, yet reliable epidemiological estimates would require inclusive, operational definitions of the concept, as well as wider knowledge dissemination among involved professionals. Whereas several manifestations have been described, including coma, vegetative state/unresponsive wakefulness syndrome and minimally conscious state, a comprehensive neurobiological definition for disorders of consciousness is still lacking. The scientific literature is primarily observational, and studies-specific aetiologies lead to disorders of consciousness. Despite advances in these disease-related forms, there remains uncertainty about whether disorders of consciousness are a disease-agnostic unitary entity with a common mechanism, prognosis or treatment response paradigm. Our knowledge of disorders of consciousness has also been hampered by heterogeneity of study designs, variables, and outcomes, leading to results that are not comparable for evidence synthesis. The different backgrounds of professionals caring for patients with disorders of consciousness and the different goals at different stages of care could partly explain this variability. The Prospective Studies working group of the Neurocritical Care Society Curing Coma Campaign was established to create a platform for observational studies and future clinical trials on disorders of consciousness and coma across the continuum of care. In this narrative review, the author panel presents limitations of prior observational clinical research and outlines practical considerations for future investigations. A narrative review format was selected to ensure that the full breadth of study design considerations could be addressed and to facilitate a future consensus-based statement (e.g. via a modified Delphi) and series of recommendations. The panel convened weekly online meetings from October 2021 to December 2022. Research considerations addressed the nosographic status of disorders of consciousness, case ascertainment and verification, selection of dependent variables, choice of covariates and measurement and analysis of outcomes and covariates, aiming to promote more homogeneous designs and practices in future observational studies. The goal of this review is to inform a broad community of professionals with different backgrounds and clinical interests to address the methodological challenges imposed by the transition of care from acute to chronic stages and to streamline data gathering for patients with disorders of consciousness. A coordinated effort will be a key to allow reliable observational data synthesis and epidemiological estimates and ultimately inform condition-modifying clinical trials.