Machine learning and the labour market: A portrait of occupational and worker inequities in Canada

Arif Jetha,Qing Liao,Faraz Vahid Shahidi,Viet Vu,Aviroop Biswas,Brendan Smith,Peter Smith

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.06.12.24308855

2024-06-13

Abstract:Introduction: Machine learning (ML) is increasingly used by Canadian workplaces. Concerningly, the impact of ML may be inequitable and disrupt social determinants of health. The aim of this study is to estimate the number of workers in occupations highly exposed to ML and describe differences in ML exposure represents according to occupational and worker sociodemographic factors. Methods: Canadian occupations were scored according to the extent to which they were made up of job tasks that could be performed by ML. Eight years of data from the Canadian Labour Force Survey were pooled and the number of Canadians in occupations with high or low exposed to machine learning were estimated. The relationship between gender, hourly wages, educational attainment and occupational job skills, experience and training requirements and ML exposure was examined using stratified logistic regression models. Results: Approximately, 1.9 million Canadians are working in occupations with high ML exposure and 744,250 workers were employed in occupations with low ML exposure. Women were more likely to be employed in occupations with high ML exposure than men. Workers with greater educational attainment and in occupations with higher wages and greater job skills requirements were more likely to experience high ML exposure. Women, especially those with less educational attainment and in jobs with greater job skills, training and experience requirements, were disproportionately exposed to ML. Conclusion: ML has the potential to widen inequities in the working population. Disadvantaged segments of the workforce may be most likely to be employed in occupations with high ML exposure. ML may have a gendered effect and disproportionately impact certain groups of women when compared to men. We provide a critical evidence base to develop strategic responses that ensure inclusion in a working world where ML is commonplace.

Occupational and Environmental Health

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper examines the impact of machine learning (ML) on the Canadian labor market, particularly how it exacerbates inequality between occupations and workers. The study estimates the number of Canadians working in high ML exposure and low ML exposure occupations, and analyzes how these exposures vary by occupation and socio-demographic characteristics (such as gender, education level, hourly wages, and job skill requirements). The research finds that approximately 1.9 million Canadians are employed in high ML exposure occupations, while around 744,250 individuals work in low ML exposure occupations. Women are more likely than men to work in high ML exposure occupations, and workers with higher education levels, higher wages, and higher skill requirements are also more likely to face high ML exposure. The study suggests that ML may amplify gender disparities and have disproportionate effects on certain groups of women. These findings have important implications for policy making and planning to ensure inclusive development in a ML-driven work environment.