Abstract:The basal ganglia (BG) play a key role in decision-making, preventing impulsive actions in some contexts while facilitating fast adaptations in others. The specific contributions of different BG structures to this nuanced behavior remain unclear, particularly under varying situations of noisy and conflicting information that necessitate ongoing adjustments in the balance between speed and accuracy. Theoretical accounts suggest that dynamic regulation of the amount of evidence required to commit to a decision (a dynamic decision boundary) may be necessary to meet these competing demands. Through the application of novel computational modeling tools in tandem with direct neural recordings from human BG areas, we find that neural dynamics in the theta band manifest as variations in a collapsing decision boundary as a function of conflict and uncertainty. We collected intracranial recordings from patients diagnosed with either Parkinson's disease (n=14) or dystonia (n=3) in the subthalamic nucleus (STN), globus pallidus internus (GPi), and externus (GPe) during their performance of a novel perceptual discrimination task in which we independently manipulated uncertainty and conflict. To formally characterize whether these task and neural components influenced decision dynamics, we leveraged modified diffusion decision models (DDMs). Behavioral choices and response time distributions were best characterized by a modified DDM in which the decision boundary collapsed over time, but where the onset and shape of this collapse varied with conflict. Moreover, theta dynamics in BG structures predicted the onset and shape of this collapse but differentially across task conditions. In STN, theta activity was related to a prolonged decision boundary (indexed by slower collapse and therefore more deliberate choices) during high-conflict situations. Conversely, rapid declines in GPe theta during low conflict conditions were related to rapidly collapsing boundaries and expedited choices, with additional complementary decision bound adjustments during high uncertainty situations. Finally, GPi theta effects were uniform across conditions, with increases in theta prolonging the collapse of decision bounds. Together, these findings provide a nuanced understanding of how our brain thwarts impulsive actions while nonetheless enabling behavioral adaptation amidst noisy and conflicting information.

Mixed representations of choice direction and outcome by GABA/glutamate cotransmitting neurons in the entopeduncular nucleus

Mixed representations of choice and outcome by GABA/glutamate cotransmitting neurons in the entopeduncular nucleus

A change of mind: Globus pallidus activity and effective connectivity during changes in choice selections

Multiple dynamic interactions from basal ganglia direct and indirect pathways mediate action selection

Basal ganglia role in learning rewarded actions and executing previously learned choices: Healthy and diseased states

Properties of Neurons in External Globus Pallidus Can Support Optimal Action Selection

How cortico-basal ganglia-thalamic subnetworks can shift decision policies to maximize reward rate

Basal ganglia network dynamics and function: Role of direct, indirect and hyper-direct pathways in action selection

Competing neural representations of choice shape evidence accumulation in humans

Opposing regulation of short-term memory by basal ganglia direct and indirect pathways that are coactive during behavior

Asymmetrical Choice-Related Ensemble Activity in Direct and Indirect-Pathway Striatal Neurons Drives Perceptual Decisions

Selective encoding of reward predictions and prediction errors by globus pallidus subpopulations

Distinct basal ganglia decision dynamics under conflict and uncertainty

GABAergic Motor Neurons Bias Locomotor Decision-Making in C. Elegans.

A computational model explains and predicts substantia nigra pars reticulata responses to pallidal and striatal inputs

Functional Dissection of Basal Ganglia Inhibitory Inputs onto Substantia Nigra Dopaminergic Neurons

Arkypallidal neurons in the external globus pallidus can mediate inhibitory control by altering competition in the striatum

Basal ganglia output - entopeduncular nucleus - coding of contextual kinematics and reward in the freely moving mouse

Superior colliculus bidirectionally modulates choice activity in frontal cortex

Dissociable roles of ventral pallidum neurons in the basal ganglia reinforcement learning network

Comparative Roles of Caudate and Putamen in the Serial Order of Behavior: Effects of Striatal Glutamate Receptor Blockade on Variable Versus Fixed Spatial Self-Ordered Sequencing in Marmosets