Accurate predictions of coexistence in natural systems require the inclusion of facilitative interactions and environmental dependency
Malyon D. Bimler,Daniel B. Stouffer,Hao Ran Lai,Margaret M. Mayfield
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2745.13030
IF: 6.381
2018-08-13
Journal of Ecology
Abstract:Coexistence between plant species is well known to depend on the outcomes of species interactions within an environmental context. The incorporation of environmental variation into empirical studies of coexistence are rare, however, due to the complex experiments needed to do so and the lack of feasible modelling approaches for determining how environmental factors alter specific coexistence mechanisms. In this article, we present a simple modelling framework for assessing how variation in species interactions across environmental gradients impact on niche overlap and fitness differences, two core determinants of coexistence. We use a novel formulation of an annual plant population dynamics model that allows for competitive and facilitative species interactions and for variation in the strength and direction of these interactions across environmental gradients. Using this framework, we examine outcomes of plant–plant interactions between four commonly co‐occurring annual plant species from Western Australian woodlands. We then determine how niche overlap and fitness differences between these species vary across three environmental gradients previously identified as important for structuring diversity patterns in this system: soil phosphorus, shade and water. We found facilitation to be a widespread phenomenon and that interactions between most species pairs shift between competitive and facilitative across multiple environmental gradients. Environmental conditions also altered the strength, direction and relative variation of both niche overlap and fitness differences in nonlinear and unpredictable ways. Synthesis. We provide a simple framework for incorporating environmental heterogeneity into explorations of coexistence mechanisms. Our findings highlight the importance of the environment in determining the outcome of species interactions and the potential for pairwise coexistence between species. The prevalence of facilitation in our system indicates a need to improve current theoretical frameworks of coexistence to include noncompetitive interactions and ways of translating these effects into explicit predictions of coexistence. Our study also suggests a need for further research into determining which factors result in consistent responses of niche overlap and fitness differences to environmental variation. Such information will improve our ability to predict outcomes of coexistence, invasion events and responses of whole communities to future environmental change. 环境因素的变动将影响物种之间的互动,进而决定它们的共存。但是,环境变数甚少被包括在实验性研究内,因为这需要复杂的实验设计以及适用的统计模型。 我们运用了一个新颖的一年生植物种群模型以探索环境变数如何影响物种之间的互动,进而影响它们之间的生态位重叠度和适应度差距。这种群模型可接纳竞争性与辅助性的物种互动,也能探测环境因素如何影响这些互动的强度和正负方向。在澳洲西部的木林内,此模型被用于探索环境因素(光量、土壤磷含量和水份)的变异如何影响四个草本植物物种之间的互动,以及物种之间的生态位相似度和适应度差距。 研究结果显示辅助性互动是个非常普遍的现象。在不同的环境下,物种的互动可在竞争性和辅助性之间交替,但是环境条件对生态位相似度和适应度差距的强度和正负方向所造成的影响是非直线性以及难以预测的。 总结. 我们提供了一个能容纳环境异质性的研究框架以了解物种之间的共存机制。我们的研究结果显示环境是一个决定物种互动和成对共存的重要因素。除了竞争性的物种互动,未来的研究和预测模型也必需含盖极为普遍的辅助性互动。我们也建议研究者发掘更多其他可以影响生态位相似度和适应度差距的环境因素,以促使我们更加了解物种共存、侵植过程和群落对未来环境变化的反应。 We provide a simple framework for incorporating environmental heterogeneity into explorations of coexistence mechanisms. We show that niche overlap and fitness differences change along three environmental gradients, including tree canopy cover (shown above in left panel, with the black line showing niche overlap and the gray line showing fitness differences for W. acuminata and H. glabra, two common annual wildflowers from our Western Australia woodland system). These changes have the potential to drive substantial shifts in coexistence outcomes in natural communities (shown theoretically in the right panel above). Our findings highlight the importance of the environment in determining the outcome of species interactions and coexistence outcomes in heterogeneous natural environments. We also found a prevalence of facilitation in our system that points to a need to improve current theoretical frameworks of coexistence to include noncompetitive interactions and ways of translating these effects into explicit predictions of coexistence. Results from our study represent a step forward, towards improving our ability to predict outcomes of coexistence, invasion events and responses of whole communities to future environmental change.
ecology,plant sciences