Abstract:Revised anxiety‐like assays that introduce continual motivational conflict may improve upon "classic" assays like the elevated plus maze or open field test. Findings suggest that classic assays may sufficiently characterize differences across genetically defined groups, but the revised 3DR may be advantageous for investigating more nuanced behavioral differences such as those stemming from environmental factors. Widely used rodent anxiety assays like the elevated plus maze (EPM) and the open field test (OFT) are conflated with rodents' natural preference for dark over light environments or protected over open spaces. The EPM and OFT have been used for decades but are often criticized by behavioral scientists. Years ago, two revised anxiety assays were designed to improve upon the "classic" tests by excluding the possibility to avoid or escape aversion. The 3‐D radial arm maze (3DR) and the 3‐D open field test (3Doft) utilize continual motivational conflict to better model anxiety; each consist of an open space connected to ambiguous paths toward uncertain escape. Despite their utility, the revised assays have not caught on. This could be because no study yet has directly compared classic and revised assays in the same animals. To remedy this, we contrasted behavior from a battery of assays (EPM, OFT, 3DR, 3Doft and a sociability test) in mice defined genetically by isogenic strain, or environmentally by postnatal experience. One major motivation for this work is to inform future studies by offering a transparent look at individual outcomes on these assays, as there is no one‐size‐fits‐all test to assess rodent anxiety‐like behavior. Findings suggest that classic assays may sufficiently characterize differences across genetically defined groups, but the revised 3DR may be advantageous for investigating more nuanced behavioral differences such as those stemming from environmental factors. Finally, exposure to multiple assays significantly affected sociability, highlighting concerns for designing and interpreting batteries of rodent behavioral tests.

In search of a conditioned place preference test to assess the severity of experimental procedures

Choice-based severity scale (CSS): assessing the relative severity of procedures from a laboratory animal's perspective

Flood-conditioned place aversion as a novel non-pharmacological aversive learning procedure in mice

Assessing negative reinforcement through simultaneous observing and committed concurrent progressive‐ratio procedures: Preliminary investigations

A Novel Method to Study Reward-Context Associations and Drug-Seeking Behaviors

The Active Place Avoidance (APA) Test, an Effective, Versatile and Repeatable Spatial Learning Task for Mice

Establishment of computer-based video-tracking conditioned place preference experiment system in mice

Examining Object Location and Object Recognition Memory in Mice

Validation of a touchscreen probabilistic reward task for mice: A reverse-translated assay with cross-species continuity

Nature and nurture: Comparing mouse behavior in classic versus revised anxiety‐like and social behavioral assays in genetically or environmentally defined groups

Determining the value of preferred goods based on consumer demand in a home-cage based test for mice

Assessing Exploratory Behavior and Memory in ICR, BALB/c and C57BL/6 Mice Using Habituation

A safe bet? Inter-laboratory variability in behaviour-based severity assessment

Assessing Exploratory Behavior and Memory in ICR, BALB/c and C57BL/6 Mice Using Habituation: Assessing Exploratory Behavior and Memory in ICR, BALB/c and C57BL/6 Mice Using Habituation

Persistent conditioned place preference to aggression experience in adult male sexually‐experienced CD‐1 mice

The Continuous Performance Test (rcpt) for Mice: a Novel Operant Touchscreen Test of Attentional Function.

Rats' performance in a suboptimal choice procedure implemented in a natural-foraging analogue

Sucrose preference test for measurement of stress-induced anhedonia in mice

Conditioned context aversion learning in the laboratory mouse

Looking beyond the standard version of the Morris water task in the assessment of mouse models of cognitive deficits

Punishment Risk Task: Monitoring anxiogenic states during goal directed actions in mice