Defective Homologous Recombination and Genomic Instability Predict Increased Responsiveness to Carbon Ion Radiotherapy in Pancreatic Cancer

Brock J. Sishc,Janapriya Saha,Elizabeth Polsdofer,Lianghao Ding,Huiming Lu,Shih-Ya Wang,Katy L. Swancutt,James H. Nicholson,Angelica Facoetti,Arnold Pompos,Mario Ciocca,Todd A. Aguilera,Michael D. Story,Anthony J. Davis
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.04.08.588534
2024-04-11
Abstract:Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) is inherently resistant to conventional chemo-and radiation-therapy. However, clinical trials showed that carbon ion radiotherapy (CIRT) with concurrent gemcitabine can be effective for treating unresectable locally advanced PDAC. In this study, we aimed to determine features that could identify patients who would benefit most from CIRT. A panel of human PDAC cell lines with various genetic backgrounds was leveraged to determine whether a subset could be identified that preferentially responds to CIRT. The cell lines displayed a differential response to CIRT as compared to γ-rays as measured by relative biological effectiveness (RBE) calculated at 10% survival, which ranged from 1.96 to 3.04. Increased radiosensitivity correlated with decreased DNA double strand break (DSB) repair as measured by γH2AX foci resolution. We determined that the cell lines most sensitive to CIRT are defective in the homologous recombination (HR) DSB repair pathway and/or have high genomic instability due to elevated replication stress. Next, this knowledge was utilized to assess whether the HR pathway could be targeted to potentiate CIRT . It was determined that pretreating a radioresistant PDAC cell line with the HR inhibitor, B02, resulted in a marked increase in sensitivity to CIRT when treated with high linear energy transfer (LET) radiation in the spread-out Bragg peak (74.1-89.3 keV/μm) but not at the entry LET (13.0-16.4 keV/μm) as opposed to that seen with a NHEJ inhibitor. These data suggest a greater therapeutic index with the combination therapy in the tumor over normal tissues based on LET distribution. These data support the notion that PDAC tumors with defects in HR and/or those with high inherent replication stress respond to CIRT without the concern for excessive normal tissue toxicity. With the advent of agents targeting HR, the difference in tumor cell response in the entry region vs within the SOBP based upon the respective LETs of those regions of the beam profile, will be superior to agents that target NHEJ.
Cancer Biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Aims to Address This paper aims to explore the molecular mechanisms of carbon ion radiotherapy (CIRT) in the treatment of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) and identify genomic markers that can predict patient response to CIRT. Specifically, the paper addresses the following points: 1. **Research Background**: - PDAC has inherent resistance to conventional chemotherapy and radiotherapy. - Clinical trials have shown that CIRT combined with gemcitabine can effectively treat locally advanced PDAC that is not surgically resectable. 2. **Research Objectives**: - Determine which genomic features can identify PDAC patients who would benefit the most from CIRT. - Use a set of human PDAC cell lines with different genetic backgrounds to determine if specific subgroups exhibit higher sensitivity to CIRT. 3. **Experimental Results**: - There are differences in cell line responses to CIRT, with relative biological effectiveness (RBE) ranging from 1.96 to 3.04. - Increased sensitivity to CIRT is associated with reduced DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair capacity. - The most sensitive cell lines exhibit homologous recombination (HR) defects and high genomic instability. 4. **Further Research**: - Investigate whether inhibiting the HR pathway can enhance the effectiveness of CIRT. - After treating radioresistant PDAC cell lines with the HR inhibitor B02, it was found that in high linear energy transfer (LET) regions (such as the spread-out Bragg peak), cell sensitivity to CIRT significantly increased. 5. **Conclusion**: - PDAC tumors with HR defects or high replication stress are more sensitive to CIRT without causing excessive toxicity to normal tissues. - This finding supports the potential use of CIRT for treating PDAC tumors with HR defects. In summary, by studying the different response mechanisms of PDAC cell lines to CIRT, the paper aims to identify genomic markers that can improve treatment outcomes, thereby better guiding clinical applications.