Noise Reduction and Localization Accuracy in a Mobile Magnetoencephalography System

Timothy Bardouille,Vanessa Smith,Elias Vajda,Carson Drake Leslie,Niall Holmes
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.03.20.585911
2024-03-25
Abstract:Magnetoencephalography (MEG) non-invasively provides important information about human brain electrophysiology. The growing use of optically pumped magnetometers (OPM) for MEG, as opposed to fixed arrays of cryogenic sensors, has opened the door for innovation in system design and use cases. For example, cryogenic MEG systems are housed in large shielded rooms to provide sufficient space for the system dewar. Here, we investigate the performance of OPM recordings inside of a cylindrical shield with a 1×2 m footprint. The efficacy of shielding was measured in terms of field attenuation and isotropy, and the value of post hoc noise reduction algorithms was also investigated. Localization accuracy was quantified for 104 OPM sensors mounted on a fixed helmet array based on simulations and recordings from a bespoke current dipole phantom. Passive shielding attenuated direct current (DC) and power line (60 Hz) fields by approximately 60 dB, and all other frequencies by 80-90 dB. Post hoc noise reduction provided an additional 5-15 dB attenuation. Substantial field anisotropy remained in the volume encompassing the sensor array. The consistency of the anisotropy over months suggests that a field nulling solution could be readily applied. A current dipole phantom generating source activity at an appropriate magnitude for the human brain generated field fluctuations on the order of 0.5-1 pT. Phantom signals were localized with 3 mm localization accuracy and no significant bias in localization was observed, which is in line with performance for cryogenic and OPM MEG systems. This validation of the performance of a small footprint MEG system opens the door for lower cost MEG installations in terms of raw materials and facility space, as well as mobile imaging systems (e.g., truck-based). Such implementations are relevant for global adoption of MEG outside of highly resourced research and clinical institutions.
Biophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to solve the problems of noise reduction and positioning accuracy in mobile magnetoencephalography (MEG) systems. Specifically, the research team focuses on how to effectively reduce environmental magnetic field noise and maintain high positioning accuracy when using cylindrical shielding. The following are the main objectives and methods of the paper: 1. **Evaluating Shielding Effectiveness**: - The research team measured the attenuation effect of the cylindrical shielding on direct - current (DC) and alternating - current (60 Hz) magnetic fields, as well as the magnetic field attenuation at other frequencies. - The effectiveness of the shielding was evaluated by the amount of magnetic field attenuation and spatial isotropy. 2. **Post - processing Noise Reduction Algorithms**: - The research team also explored the effect of post - processing noise reduction algorithms to further reduce the impact of noise. 3. **Verifying Positioning Accuracy**: - By simulating and actually recording current dipole phantom signals, the research team quantified the positioning accuracy of 104 optically pumped magnetometer (OPM) sensors. - The positioning accuracy of the phantom signals was used to verify the performance of the system. ### Main Findings - **Shielding Effectiveness**: - Passive shielding can attenuate direct - current (DC) and 60 Hz power - line noise by approximately 60 dB, and the noise at other frequencies can be attenuated by 80 - 90 dB. - The post - processing noise reduction algorithms provide an additional 5 - 15 dB attenuation. - **Spatial Anisotropy**: - Although there is significant spatial anisotropy inside the shielding, this anisotropy remains consistent over several months, indicating that it can be corrected by field - cancellation techniques. - **Positioning Accuracy**: - The source activity generated using current dipole phantoms is within the appropriate range of human brain magnetic field fluctuations (0.5 - 1 pT), and the positioning accuracy of the phantom signals reaches 3 mm without obvious positioning deviation. - This result is comparable to the performance of traditional cryogenic MEG and OPM MEG systems. ### Conclusion This study verifies the performance of the small - sized cylindrical - shielded MEG system, indicating that it has advantages in terms of cost and space requirements and is suitable for a wider range of institutions and mobile applications. These results provide an important basis for further promoting and applying OPM MEG technology.