Identifying factors related to nondisclosure during clinical supervision among Chinese supervisees: Study protocol

Alberto Stefana,Eric A. Youngstrom

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.02.02.24302184

2024-02-03

Abstract:Psychoanalysis is gaining widespread popularity as a therapeutic model in China. However, the absence of local accredited psychoanalytic training institutes necessitates that Chinese trainees and clinicians often receive supervision from European or American supervisors through online platforms. A key component of effective supervision is the willingness of the supervisees to disclose. This openness not only solidifies the supervisory alliance but also improves the supervisee’s self-awareness, self-efficacy, knowledge, and therapeutic skills. Emerging research highlights the significant role of cultural factors in shaping supervisory relationships. Our study aims to: (a) compare the disclosure and nondisclosure rates in clinical supervision between Chinese supervisees and their counterparts from Western cultures, and (b) examine the association between these behaviors and variables related to the therapeutic process among Chinese supervisees. We will employ a cross-sectional design, targeting Chinese psychoanalytic clinicians, both trainees and licensed professionals, engaged in individual clinical supervision. Recruitment will be primarily through the China American Psychoanalytic Alliance mailing list, complemented by snowball sampling. Data will be collected through an online survey hosted on the REDCap platform, focusing on the primary clinical supervisor of the participants and their supervisory experience. This research aims to provide insights that could enable supervisors of Chinese trainees to better understand and adapt to the relational dynamics in supervisory contexts. Additionally, it will lay the foundation for more detailed qualitative investigations into the experiences of Chinese psychoanalytic supervisees, potentially informing future supervisory practices and training methodologies.

Psychiatry and Clinical Psychology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The research aims to explore the phenomenon of non-disclosure of relevant information by Chinese trainee psychoanalysts during clinical supervision and its related factors, and to compare these findings with trainees from Western cultural backgrounds. Specifically, the study has two main objectives:

1. **To compare the proportion of disclosure and non-disclosure of information in clinical supervision between Chinese trainees and trainees from Western cultural backgrounds**: Through this comparison, the study hopes to reveal how cultural differences influence communication patterns in clinical supervision.

2. **To examine the association between Chinese trainees' disclosure and non-disclosure behaviors and therapy process variables**: These variables include the quality of the supervisor-trainee relationship, the supervisor's attitude and style, and satisfaction with clinical supervision. By analyzing these associations, the study attempts to identify key factors that influence trainees' disclosure of information during supervision.

The study adopts a cross-sectional design, with participants being Chinese psychoanalysts or psychoanalytic therapists (including those in training and those already qualified), recruited through channels such as the China American Psychoanalytic Alliance (CAPA). Data collection is completed through online surveys, covering multiple aspects of the supervision process, including but not limited to the trainees' personal and professional characteristics, levels of anxiety about supervision, the supervisor's attitude and style, the quality of the supervisor-trainee relationship, willingness to disclose, and satisfaction with clinical supervision.

The study hypothesizes that Chinese trainees, compared to their counterparts in Western countries, have a lower average disclosure rate in clinical supervision, and higher non-disclosure rates are associated with higher levels of anxiety, lower self-esteem, weaker supervisor-trainee relationships, and poorer interpersonal sensitivity of the supervisor. Additionally, the study hypothesizes that trainees with lower satisfaction with supervision will exhibit more non-disclosure behaviors.

This research is expected to provide important insights into the unique experiences of Chinese trainee psychoanalysts during the clinical supervision process and to offer guidance for optimizing supervision practices. The findings will help supervisors better adapt to working relationships with Chinese trainees, thereby improving the effectiveness and quality of clinical supervision.