Creating something out of nothing: Symbolic and non-symbolic representations of numerical zero in the human brain

Benjy Barnett,Stephen M Fleming

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.01.30.577906

2024-05-22

Abstract:Representing the quantity zero as a symbolic concept is considered a unique achievement of abstract human thought. Despite considerable progress in understanding the neural code supporting natural numbers, how numerical zero is encoded in the human brain remains unknown. We find that both non-symbolic empty sets (the absence of dots on a screen) and symbolic zero ('0') occupy ordinal positions along graded neural number lines within posterior association cortex. Neural representations of zero are partly independent of numerical format, exhibiting distance effects with countable numerosities in the opposing (symbolic or non-symbolic) format. Our results show that format-invariant neural magnitude codes extend to judgements of numerical zero and help motivate theoretical accounts in which representations of symbolic zero are grounded in more basic representations of sensory absences.

Neuroscience

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the neural representation of the number zero in the human brain. Specifically, the researchers explored the following points:

1. **Conceptualization of the number zero**: The number zero, as a symbolic concept, is regarded as a unique achievement of abstract human thinking. Although considerable research progress has been made in the neural coding of natural numbers, how the number zero is encoded in the human brain remains unknown. The researchers wanted to know whether the number zero, like natural numbers, occupies an ordered position on the neural number line.

2. **Non - symbolic and symbolic zero**: The researchers examined whether the neural representations of the non - symbolic empty set (no dots on the screen) and the symbolic zero (‘0’) in the brain are similar or different. They hoped to understand whether these representations are partly independent of the numerical format and whether they show a distance effect from the counted values.

3. **Format - invariant neural representation**: The researchers further explored whether the format - invariant neural magnitude code extends to the judgment of the number zero. They hoped to support the theoretical view that the representation of the symbolic zero is rooted in the more basic representation of sensory absence.

### Research methods
To answer the above questions, the researchers designed two different numerical tasks and used magnetoencephalography (MEG) data to reveal the representational content in the neural responses. These two tasks are:
- **Non - symbolic matching task**: Participants observed two dot - pattern arrays presented in sequence and judged whether they contained the same number of dots. The number of dots ranged from zero to five.
- **Symbolic averaging task**: Participants observed a series of rapidly and consecutively presented symbolic numbers (0 to 5) and reported which group of numbers had a higher or lower average.

### Main findings
- **Gradation of neural representation**: The study found that both the non - symbolic empty set and the symbolic zero occupy an ordered position on the graded neural number line in the posterior association cortex. These representations are partly independent of the numerical format and are similar to the distance effect of countable values.
- **Representation across formats**: The symbolic zero can predict the non - symbolic empty set, and vice versa. This indicates that the neural representation of the number zero is somewhat shared across different formats.
- **Location in the posterior association cortex**: The study also located the position of the abstract number - zero representation in the posterior association cortex, expanding the role of the parietal cortex in human numerical cognition.

Through these studies, the paper provides important insights into understanding the neural representation of the number zero in the human brain, further enriching our understanding of the cognitive basis of abstract mathematical concepts.