Bridging the resolution-sectioning gap in stimulated emission depletion microscopy: theory and experiment

Michael Belsley,Joana Soares-de-Oliveira,António J. Pereira

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.01.18.576258

2024-01-23

Abstract:Microscopes generally exhibit superior performance in 2D compared to 3D. Fluorescence super-resolution imaging often intensifies this discrepancy, such as with the gold-standard vortex-based stimulated emission depletion (STED) microscope, which narrows the point-spread function only laterally. In this study, we developed a semi-analytical theory based on the Nijboer-Zernike expansion, conducted simulations and performed experiments to establish the merits of the alternative bivortex-based STED. We find that this mode reduces the axial-lateral resolution mismatch and effectively emulates noisier multi-beam approaches by providing access to point-spread function geometries that are strictly forbidden to the two conventional single-beam modes, 2D-STED and z-STED. Notably, theory and experiment indicate that, besides filling the gap, bivortex STED delivers a higher signal-to-background than the two modes it bridges.

Biophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to bridge the gap between lateral resolution and axial resolution in stimulated emission depletion (STED) microscopy. Specifically:

1. **Mismatch between lateral and axial resolutions**: Traditional STED microscopes perform well in two - dimensional (2D) imaging, but in three - dimensional (3D) imaging, especially in terms of axial resolution, they perform poorly. This results in a mismatch between lateral resolution and axial resolution. Especially when dealing with thicker or noisier biological samples, this mismatch can significantly reduce image contrast.

2. **Limitations of existing technologies**:
- **2D - STED**: Although it performs excellently in lateral resolution, it has poor axial resolution, cannot effectively filter background noise, and cannot distinguish different planes.
- **z - STED**: Although it has a significant improvement in axial resolution, it has a lower lateral resolution and is prone to producing "ghost" images, that is, false images generated because the secondary peaks of the excitation point spread function (PSF) are not completely covered.

3. **Deficiencies of multi - beam methods**: Although multi - beam methods can improve axial resolution to a certain extent, they will introduce more noise and are complex to implement.

To solve these problems, the author proposes a new STED mode - bivortex STED. This mode uses a special phase mask, combining the characteristics of single - vortex and top - hat phase masks, and can significantly improve axial resolution while maintaining a high lateral resolution. In addition, bivortex STED can also provide a higher signal - to - background ratio (SBR), thus showing better performance when dealing with complex biological samples.

In conclusion, this paper aims to solve the problem of mismatch between lateral and axial resolutions in traditional STED microscopes in 3D imaging by developing and validating the bivortex STED mode, thereby improving the overall imaging quality and application range.