A Randomized Controlled Double-Blinded Split-Face Prospective Clinical Trial to Assess the Efficacy, Safety, and Tolerability of a Novel 3-Step Routine Compared to Benzyl Peroxide for the Treatment of Mild to Moderate Acne Vulgaris

Alison Gern,Jessica Walter,Shuai Xu,Paras P. Vakharia
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.11.12.23298113
2024-02-11
Abstract:Adult acne vulgaris affects up to 43-51% of individuals. While there are numerous treatment options for acne including topical, oral, and energy-based approaches, benzoyl peroxide (BPO) is a popular over the counter (OTC) treatment. Although BPO monotherapy has a long history of efficacy and safety, it suffers from several disadvantages, most notably, skin irritation, particularly for treatment naïve patients. In this prospective, randomized, controlled, split-face study, we evaluated the comparative efficacy, safety, and tolerability of a novel 3-step azelaic acid, salicylic acid and graduated retinol regimen (Geologie Clear System) versus a common OTC BPO-based regimen (Proactiv Solution) over 12 weeks. A total of 37 adult subjects with self-reported mild to moderate acne vulgaris were recruited. A total of 21 subjects underwent a 2-week washout period and completed the full study with 3 dropping out due to product irritation from the BPO routine, and 13 being lost to follow-up. Detailed tolerability surveys were conducted at Week 4. Additional surveys on tolerability and product preferences were collected monthly, at Week 4, Week 8, and Week 12. A blinded board-certified dermatologist objectively scored the presence and type of acne lesions (open or closed comedones, papules, pustules, nodules, and cysts) at baseline, Week 4, Week 8, and Week 12. Patients photographed themselves and uploaded the images using personal mobile phones. Detailed Week 4 survey results showed across 25 domains of user-assessed product performance, Geologie outperformed the BPO routine in 19 (76%) which included domains in preference (e.g. “I would use this in the future), performance (“my skin improved” and “helped my acne clear up faster”). Geologie users reported less facial redness, itching, and burning, though differences did not reach statistical significance. In terms of efficacy, both products performed similarly, reducing total acne lesions by 36% (Geologie) and 40% (BPO routine) by Week 12. Overall, accounting for user preferences and tolerability Geologie was more preferred than the BPO routine in 79% of domains (22/28). Differences in objective acne lesion reduction were not statistically significant (p=0.97). In a randomized split-face study, a 3-step azelaic acid, salicylic acid, and graduated retinol regimen delivered similar acne lesion reduction, fewer user dropouts, greater user tolerability, and higher use preference compared to a 3-step BPO routine based in a cohort of participants with mild-to-moderate acne vulgaris.
Dermatology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to evaluate the efficacy, safety, and tolerability of a novel three-step skincare regimen (Geologie Clear System) compared to a commonly used benzoyl peroxide (BPO) skincare regimen (Proactiv Solution) in the treatment of mild to moderate acne vulgaris (adult acne). The study employed a randomized controlled double-blind split-face trial design to compare the effects of the two skincare regimens. ### Research Objectives: - **Evaluate Efficacy**: Determine whether the novel three-step skincare regimen can effectively reduce the number of acne lesions. - **Evaluate Safety**: Ensure that the safety of the novel skincare regimen is not inferior to the BPO regimen. - **Evaluate Tolerability**: Compare the degree of skin irritation and user acceptance between the two skincare regimens. ### Key Findings: - **Similar Efficacy**: After 12 weeks of treatment, both skincare regimens significantly reduced the number of acne lesions, with the Geologie Clear System reducing lesions by 36% and the BPO regimen by 40%, showing no statistically significant difference between the two. - **Better Tolerability**: The Geologie Clear System demonstrated better tolerability in terms of skin erythema, itching, and burning sensation, especially more noticeable at week 4. - **Higher User Preference**: Most users expressed a preference for the Geologie Clear System, particularly in terms of future usage intention, skin feel, and overall preference. ### Conclusion: In summary, this novel three-step skincare regimen (including azelaic acid, salicylic acid, and gradually increasing concentrations of retinol) is comparable in efficacy to the BPO regimen in treating mild to moderate acne vulgaris but performs better in terms of tolerability and user preference. This suggests that for adult acne patients seeking over-the-counter treatment options, the Geologie Clear System may be a better choice.