Factors affecting macromolecule orientations in thin films formed in cryo-EM

Swati Yadav,Vinothkumar Kutti Ragunath

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.11.06.565913

2024-06-18

Abstract:The formation of a vitrified thin film embedded with randomly oriented macromolecules is an essential prerequisite for cryogenic sample electron microscopy. Most commonly, this is achieved using the plunge freeze method described nearly 40 years ago. Although this is a robust method, the behaviour of different macromolecules shows great variation upon freezing and often needs to be optimized to obtain an isotropic, high-resolution reconstruction. For a macromolecule in such a film, the probability of encountering the airwater interface in the time between blotting and freezing and adopting preferred orientations is very high. 3D reconstruction using preferentially oriented particles often leads to anisotropic and uninterpretable maps. Currently, there are no general solutions to this prevalent issue, but several approaches largely focusing on sample preparation with the use of additives and novel grid modifications have been attempted. In this study, the effect of physical and chemical factors on the orientations of macromolecules was investigated through an analysis of select well-studied macromolecules and important parameters that determine the behaviour of proteins on cryo-EM grids were revealed. These insights highlight the nature of interactions that cause preferred orientations and can be utilized to systematically address orientation bias for any given macromolecule and provide a framework to design small-molecule additives to enhance sample stability and behaviour.

Biochemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly discusses the orientation problem of macromolecules in thin ice layers in cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). The study found that macromolecules may interact with the air-water interface (AWI) during the freezing process, leading to denaturation, dissociation, specific orientation, or complete avoidance of holes, thereby affecting high-resolution reconstruction. In some cases, this limits the resolution of structural analysis.

The authors reveal the key parameters affecting protein orientation by analyzing selected known macromolecules, including physical and chemical factors. They found that the preferential orientation of macromolecules is a common bottleneck for determining high-resolution structures. Although various methods have been attempted to address this issue, such as changing the sample preparation process, using additives and novel grids, there is no universally applicable solution.

In the study, researchers tested the influence of different types of surfactants (such as cationic, anionic, and nonionic surfactants) on the orientation distribution of macromolecules. The results showed that the charge nature of surfactants has a significant impact on the orientation of macromolecules, while the influence of carbon chain length and saturation is minor. For example, the cationic surfactant CTAB improved the orientation distribution of certain proteins, while the anionic surfactant SLS may lead to lower resolution.

Furthermore, the study also found that recombinant proteins with exposed multiple histidine tags (such as SARS-CoV-2 spike protein and β-galactosidase) exhibited biased orientation in thin ice layers, which may be related to the presence of tags.

In summary, the paper aims to provide a framework for designing small molecule additives to enhance sample stability and behavior by understanding the interaction properties leading to orientation bias, and systematically address the orientation problem of specific macromolecules.