Abstract:Mesocarnivores must balance the negative (competition) and positive (carrion provisioning) effects of dominant apex carnivores to coexist in shared landscapes. How mesocarnivores navigate such top-down effects have typically been examined through a risk-reward lens. However, the risks accrued by mesocarnivores might not be even across all apex-mesocarnivore pairings in multi-carnivore systems, and instead can be mediated through species-specific interactions. Using remote-camera surveys from 2021-2023, we estimated apex (wolf, cougar) and mesocarnivore (red fox, coyote) spatial overlap, occupancy, temporal activity, and fine-scale behaviors in northern Yellowstone National Park, USA. Additionally, we monitored GPS-collared wolf and cougar predation from 2016-2023 and recorded red fox and coyote mortalities and scavenging events at these locations. Red foxes and coyotes were ubiquitous in our study area with high naive occupancy, despite abundant wolves and cougars. Coyote occupancy was positively associated with wolf occupancy, but exhibited marginal avoidance of cougars. Photo-detection probabilities of both mesocarnivores doubled in the 24 hours following apex carnivore detections, with the exception of coyotes following cougars. Overall latency of coyote detections was longest following cougar detections and shortest following wolves, while foxes exhibited no such difference. Further, coyotes were most active when wolves and cougars were collectively least active. Red foxes were nocturnal and appeared less sensitive to wolf and cougar activities, but avoided coyote peak times. Coyotes were more prevalent scavengers than red foxes at apex carnivore kills, but scavenging often had lethal consequences. We found that when wolves kill coyotes, it was typically when coyotes attempted to scavenge from wolf kills, while cougars killed and consumed coyotes as prey. Thus wolves act as competitors for coyotes, while cougars are both predators and competitors. This distinction possibly explains coyote avoidance of cougars but attraction to wolves. Mesocarnivores in Yellowstone leverage foraging benefits from associating with apex carnivores. However, these benefits are burdened by associating with wolves and cougars whose contrasting hunting modes and habitat preferences yield separate risks. Disparate costs to mesocarnivores contingent upon apex carnivore behavior offer novel insights into carnivore community ecology, and call for a more nuanced analysis of trophic interactions.

Different coexistence patterns between apex carnivores and mesocarnivores based on temporal, spatial, and dietary niche partitioning analysis in Qilian Mountain National Park, China

Different coexistence patterns between apex carnivores and mesocarnivores based on temporal, spatial, and dietary niche partitioning analysis in Qilian Mountain National Park, China

Spatio-temporal Coexistence of Sympatric Mesocarnivores with a Single Apex Carnivore in a Fine-Scale Landscape

Coexistence Mechanisms of Small Carnivores in a Near-Pristine Area Within the Mountains of Southwest China

Spatial co-occurrence and temporal activity patterns of sympatric mesocarnivores guild in Qinling Mountains

Dietary diversity and niche partitioning of carnivores across the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau of China using DNA metabarcoding

Spatial Co-Occurrence and Activity Patterns of Mesocarnivores in the Temperate Forests of Southwest China

Spatial and temporal differentiation are not distinct but are covariant for facilitating coexistence of small and medium-sized carnivores in Southwestern China

Habitat Selection Differences of Two Sympatric Large Carnivores in the Southwestern Mountains of China

Temporal Response of Mesocarnivores to Human Activity and Infrastructure in Taihang Mountains, Central North China: Shifts in Activity Patterns and Their Overlap

Prey partitioning and livestock consumption in the world’s richest large carnivore assemblage

Food webs reveal coexistence mechanisms and community organization in carnivores

The Ecological Roles of Medium and Small Carnivores in the Terrestrial Animal Community in Liancheng National Nature Reserve, China

Daily Activity Rhythms of Animals in the Southwest Mountains, China: Influences of Interspecific Relationships and Seasons

Competition and Coexistence among Terrestrial Mammalian Carnivores

Coexistence of Two Sympatric Flagship Carnivores in the Human-Dominated Forest Landscapes of Northeast Asia

Temporal niche partitioning among sympatric wild and domestic ungulates between warm and cold seasons

Species-specific interactions with apex carnivores yield unique benefits and burdens for mesocarnivores

Limited spatiotemporal niche partitioning among mesocarnivores in Gorongosa National Park, Mozambique

Interactions between carnivore species: limited spatiotemporal partitioning between apex predator and smaller carnivores in a Mediterranean protected area

Spatial Separation of Prey from Livestock Facilitates Coexistence of a Specialized Large Carnivore with Human Land Use