The Virtual Goniometer: A new method for measuring angles on 3D models of fragmentary bone and lithics

Katrina Yezzi-Woodley,Jeff Calder,Peter J. Olver,Annie Melton,Paige Cody,Thomas Huffstutler,Alexander Terwilliger,Martha Tappen,Reed Coil,Gilbert Tostevin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2011.04898
2020-11-25
Abstract:The contact goniometer is a commonly used tool in lithic and zooarchaeological analysis, despite suffering from a number of shortcomings due to the physical interaction between the measuring implement, the object being measured, and the individual taking the measurements. However, lacking a simple and efficient alternative, researchers in a variety of fields continue to use the contact goniometer to this day. In this paper, we present a new goniometric method that we call the virtual goniometer, which takes angle measurements virtually on a 3D model of an object. The virtual goniometer allows for rapid data collection, and for the measurement of many angles that cannot be physically accessed by a manual goniometer. We compare the intra-observer variability of the manual and virtual goniometers, and find that the virtual goniometer is far more consistent and reliable. Furthermore, the virtual goniometer allows for precise replication of angle measurements, even among multiple users, which is important for reproducibility of goniometric-based research. The virtual goniometer is available as a plug-in in the open source mesh processing packages Meshlab and Blender, making it easily accessible to researchers exploring the potential for goniometry to improve archaeological methods and address anthropological questions.
Numerical Analysis,Computational Geometry,Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to solve a series of problems existing in traditional contact goniometers in archaeological and zooarchaeological analyses. Specifically, these problems include: 1. **Measurement accuracy and consistency**: - The measurement results of contact goniometers are affected by physical contact, resulting in potentially large differences in measurement results among different operators. - During the measurement process, the contact between the goniometer and the surface of the measured object depends on the operator's skills and judgment, which is prone to introduce human errors. 2. **Measurement range limitations**: - For some complex, curved - surface or irregular - shaped objects (such as bone fragments or stone tools), it is difficult to accurately place the contact goniometer and some angles cannot be measured. - Some very sharp edges or narrow spaces cannot be measured by the contact goniometer. 3. **Low measurement efficiency**: - Manually measuring each angle takes a long time, and for large - scale studies involving thousands of samples, the workload is huge and time - consuming. 4. **Poor data repeatability**: - Since the contact goniometer depends on manual operation, the measurement results among different researchers may be inconsistent, affecting the repeatability and reliability of the study. To solve the above problems, the author proposes a new virtual angle - measuring method - **virtual goniometer**. This method uses 3D models for virtual angle measurement and has the following advantages: - **High precision and consistency**: The virtual goniometer can measure angles more accurately and has higher repeatability among different users. - **Wide applicability**: It can measure angles that cannot be reached by traditional contact goniometers and is suitable for various complex - shaped objects. - **Efficient data collection**: Compared with manual measurement, the virtual goniometer can quickly obtain a large amount of angle data. - **Easy to use and popularize**: The virtual goniometer is integrated as a plug - in into open - source mesh processing software (such as Meshlab and Blender), which is convenient for researchers to use. Through these improvements, the virtual goniometer provides a more reliable, efficient and repeatable measurement tool for archaeological and zooarchaeological research.