Emergence of Chern insulating states in non-Magic angle twisted bilayer graphene

Cheng Shen,Jianghua Ying,Le Liu,Jianpeng Liu,Na Li,Shuopei Wang,Jian Tang,Yanchong Zhao,Yanbang Chu,Kenji Watanabe,Takashi Taniguchi,Rong Yang,Dongxia Shi,Fanming Qu,Li Lu,Wei Yang,Guangyu Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0256-307X/38/4/047301

2021-03-11

Abstract:Twisting two layers into a magic angle (MA) of ~1.1° is found essential to create low energy flat bands and the resulting correlated insulating, superconducting, and magnetic phases in twisted bilayer graphene (TBG). While most of previous works focus on revealing these emergent states in MA-TBG, a study of the twist angle dependence, which helps to map an evolution of these phases, is yet less explored. Here, we report a magneto-transport study on one non-magic angle TBG device, whose twist angle {\theta} changes from 1.25° at one end to 1.43° at the other. For {\theta}=1.25°, we observe an emergence of topological insulating states at hole side with a sequence of Chern number |C|=4-|v|, where v is the number of electrons (holes) in moiré unite cell. When {\theta}>1.25°, the Chern insulator from flat band disappears and evolves into fractal Hofstadter butterfly quantum Hall insulator where magnetic flux in one moiré unite cell matters. Our observations will stimulate further theoretical and experimental investigations on the relationship between electron interactions and non-trivial band topology.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether topological insulating states (especially Chern insulating states) can emerge in Non - Magic Angle Twisted Bilayer Graphene (NMA - TBG) and its mechanism. Specifically, the researchers explored how electron interactions affect the formation of these topological states at different twist angles, especially when the twist angles are close to but not equal to the magic angle, and also explored the competitive relationship between these states and Hofstadter butterfly spectra.

The key findings of the paper include:
1. **At θ = 1.25°**, a series of topological insulating states with Chern number |𝐶| = 4−|𝑣| were observed, where \(v\) is the number of electrons (or holes) filled in the moiré unit cell. This indicates that even under non - magic - angle conditions, strong electron interactions can still lead to the breaking of time - reversal symmetry (T - symmetry), thereby generating topologically non - trivial Chern insulating states.
2. **When θ > 1.25°**, the Chern insulating states caused by flat bands disappear, and the system evolves into a fractal Hofstadter butterfly quantum Hall insulating state that depends on the magnetic flux within the moiré unit cell. This means that as the twist angle increases, the kinetic energy of electrons increases, weakening the electron - electron interactions and making it difficult to maintain topologically non - trivial states.
3. **The relationship between electron interactions and non - trivial band topology**: The study reveals that under non - magic - angle conditions, electron interactions are still a key factor in determining whether the system can form topologically non - trivial states. In addition, the experiment also shows that under a weak magnetic field, the breaking of time - reversal symmetry can be achieved through the orbital Zeeman effect, thereby forming Chern insulating states.

In conclusion, by studying the magnetic transport properties of NMA - TBG at different twist angles, this paper not only expands our understanding of the regions outside the magic angle but also provides a new perspective for exploring the complex relationship between electron interactions and topological properties.