Abstract:Editor, We read with great interest the article by Theocharis et al. (2005). In their paper, the authors presented the results of combined phacoemulsification and pars plana vitrectomy in treating patients with macular hole. We would like to raise a few points with regard to this article that may help to broaden the discussion. Firstly, 32 (84%) patients in a series of 38 were said to have achieved successful macular hole closure postoperatively. This is certainly an encouraging result, but we noticed that successful macular hole closure was defined by the authors as ‘flattening of the edges of the hole with no evidence of subretinal fluid’. We think this might be too loose a criterion for defining successful macular hole closure. We would suggest the addition of stricter and more objective criteria, including clinical methods such as the Watzke−Allen test and investigative methods such as optical coherence tomography (OCT). We believe OCT provides excellent resolution of a cross-section of the macula and can be used as an objective indicator of macular hole closure. We would be interested to know if OCT had been performed in this series of patients postoperatively and if so, what the results were. Secondly, the authors used indocyanine green (ICG) as a dye for assisting internal limiting membrane (ILM) peeling in all their patients. While we agree that ICG provides effective staining of the ILM, since 2004 an increasing number of studies have reported the toxic effects of ICG on the retina, which include retinal pigment epithelial changes and optic atrophy (Cheng et al. 2005; Posselt et al. 2005). We would like to know if the authors have observed any similar toxic effects that may have been induced by ICG in their series of patients. In order to avoid possible toxic effects of ICG on the retina, in 2004 our centre shifted to using alternative adjuncts, including trypan blue and triamcinolone actonide, to assist in ILM peeling. Both agents appear to have better safety profiles than ICG (Gale et al. 2004). According to our experience, trypan blue is as effective as ICG in staining the ILM and has certainly enhanced the process of membrane peeling. Finally, we would like to echo the authors' conclusion that combined phacoemulsification and pars plana vitrectomy for macular hole repair have many advantages, including clearer intraoperative visualization, which, in turn make the procedure safer and more effective and give a better postoperative visual outcome. On the other hand, we are also concerned about how much postoperative visual improvement is attributable to macular hole surgery alone if combined surgeries are attempted. We believe more prospective randomized trials will be needed to resolve this issue.

Combined 23-gauge, sutureless transconjunctival vitrectomy with phacoemulsification without face down posturing for the repair of idiopathic macular holes

Traumatic Macular Hole Study: a Multicenter Comparative Study Between Immediate Vitrectomy and Six-Month Observation for Spontaneous Closure

Outcomes of 25-Gauge Vitrectomy with Air Tamponade for Idiopathic Macular Hole Repair Surgery

Efficacy of vitrectomy and air tamponade for idiopathic macular hole

Observation on the efficacy of vitrectomy at posterior pole and minimal gas tamponade for the treatment of idiopathic macular hole

AUTOLOGOUS BLOOD CLOT COVERING INSTEAD OF GAS TAMPONADE FOR MACULAR HOLES

360-degree pedicled inverted internal limiting membrane flap technique without face-down posturing for large idiopathic macular holes: a retrospective case series

A study of the effectiveness of different operative methods on 37 cases of macular hole with retinal detachment

Combined Phacoemulsification and Pars Plana Vitrectomy for Macular Hole Treatment

Macular hole repair: the effect of size and nonsupine posture on postoperative outcomes

25Gauge Vitrectomy Combined with Companded Internal Limited Membrane Peeling for Idiopathic Macular Hole

Vitrectomy Combined with Lens Capsule Flap Transplantation in the Treatment of High Myopia Macular Hole Retinal Detachment: Study Protocol for a Prospective Randomised Controlled Trial

Postoperative anatomical and functional outcomes of different stages of high myopia macular hole

Effectiveness of Inverted Internal Limiting Membrane Flap Technique Combined with Sterile Air Tamponade Surgery on Managing Idiopathic Macular Hole

Clinical efficacy of vitrectomy combined with modified inverted internal limiting membrane flap covering technique for complicated macular hole

A clinical study of vitrectomy for traumatic macular hole

EFFICACY OF AIR TAMPONADE TREATMENT OF IDIOPATHIC MACULAR HOLES OF DIFFERENT DIAMETERS AND OF FOLLOW-UP INTRAVITREAL AIR TAMPONADE FOR PERSISTENT HOLES

The removal of the internal limiting membrane without any assistant staining agent in the management of macular holes

The Anatomical and Functional Outcomes of 23-Gauge Transconjunctival Sutureless Vitrectomy in Pseudophakic Retinal Detachment: A Prospective Interventional Study

Vitrectomy combined with inverted internal limiting membrane flap insertion or single-layered flap covering technique for highly myopic macular holes with macular retinoschisis

Clinical efficacy of vitrectomy combined with inverted internal limiting membrane flap technique for macular hole retinal detachment of high myopia