Fengqing Chao,Patrick Gerland,Alex R. Cook,Leontine Alkema
Abstract:The sex ratio at birth (SRB) is defined as the ratio of male to female live births. The SRB imbalance in parts of the world over the past several decades is a direct consequence of sex-selective abortion, driven by the co-existence of son preference, readily available technology of prenatal sex determination, and fertility decline. Estimation and projection of the degree of SRB imbalance is complicated because of variability in SRB reference levels and because of the uncertainty associated with SRB observations. We develop Bayesian hierarchical time series mixture models for SRB estimation and scenario-based projections for all countries from 1950 to 2100. We model the SRB regional and national reference levels, and the fluctuation around national reference levels. We identify countries at risk of SRB imbalances and model both (i) the absence or presence of sex ratio transitions in such countries and, if present, (ii) the transition process. The transition model of SRB imbalance captures three stages (increase, stagnation and convergence back to SRB baselines). The model identifies countries with statistical evidence of SRB inflation in a fully Bayesian approach. The scenario-based SRB projections are based on the sex ratio transition model with varying assumptions regarding the occurrence of a sex ratio transition in at-risk countries. Projections are used to quantify the future burden of missing female births due to sex-selective abortions under different scenarios.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the estimation and prediction of the imbalance in the global sex ratio at birth (SRB). Specifically, the author has developed a Bayesian hierarchical time - series mixture model for estimating and scenario - based predicting the sex ratio at birth and its imbalance in all countries from 1950 to 2100. The paper focuses on how to accurately estimate and predict the imbalance in the sex ratio at birth due to selective abortion, especially in those countries where such an imbalance exists or may be at risk of existing.
### Background and Problem Description
- **Sex Ratio at Birth (SRB)**: Defined as the ratio of male to female live births. Under natural circumstances, this ratio usually fluctuates between 1.03 and 1.07.
- **Causes of Imbalance**: In recent years, the sex ratio at birth in some Asian countries and Eastern European regions has increased significantly, mainly due to selective abortion. The reasons behind this include:
- **Strong preference for sons over daughters**: Provides the motivation.
- **Declining fertility rate**: Leads to a smaller family size and increases the willingness for selective abortion.
- **Popularization of sex - identification technology**: Provides the means.
### Research Challenges
- **Variation in Baseline Levels**: There are differences in the baseline levels of the natural sex ratio at birth in different regions and countries.
- **Data Uncertainty**: There is uncertainty in the observed sex ratio at birth data.
### Solutions
- **Bayesian Hierarchical Time - Series Mixture Model**: This model can handle the differences in baseline levels between different countries and regions and can capture the changing trend of the sex ratio at birth.
- **Identification of Risk Countries**: Identify countries where an imbalance in the sex ratio at birth may have occurred or has already occurred through statistical methods.
- **Scenario Prediction**: Based on different assumptions, construct scenario predictions for the future sex ratio at birth, including:
- **Scenario 1 (S1)**: Continue to predict the imbalance in the sex ratio at birth only in countries with strong statistical evidence.
- **Scenario 2 (S2)**: Predict the imbalance in the sex ratio at birth according to the respective risk probabilities in all risk countries.
- **Scenario 3 (S3)**: Assume that an imbalance in the sex ratio at birth occurs with a 100% probability in all risk countries.
### Model Structure
- **Basic Model**: For countries not affected by selective abortion, the following model is used:
\[
\Theta_{c,t}=\beta_c \eta_{c,t}(\phi)
\]
where \(\beta_c\) is the baseline sex ratio at birth in country \(c\), and \(\eta_{c,t}(\phi)\) is the fluctuation factor for a specific year.
- **Imbalance Model**: For at - risk countries, the model is as follows:
\[
\Theta_{c,t}=\hat{\beta}_{c}^{[M1]} \eta_{c,t}(\hat{\phi}^{[M1]})+\delta_c \Omega_{c,t}(\zeta)
\]
where \(\delta_c\) is a binary variable indicating whether an imbalance in the sex ratio at birth has occurred; \(\Omega_{c,t}(\zeta)\) is a measure of the degree of imbalance.
### Prediction Methods
- **Scenario 1 (S1)**: Only predict the imbalance in countries with strong statistical evidence.
- **Scenario 2 (S2)**: Predict according to the risk probability of each country.
- **Scenario 3 (S3)**: Assume that all at - risk countries will experience an imbalance.
### Conclusion
This study, through the Bayesian hierarchical time - series mixture model, provides a systematic method for estimating and predicting the global imbalance in the sex ratio at birth. This method can not only accurately identify at - risk countries but also predict future trends in the sex ratio at birth according to different scenario assumptions, providing an important reference for policymakers.